Ed nominee, governor needs to clarify position on charter schools

Posted

When Gov. Phil Scott appoints someone to a cabinet position the supposition is that the nominee has the skill set to do the job, the experience to create the trust necessary among those most directly affected, and a vision that matches his own. That was the expectation when he announced Zoie Saunders as his person to take over the Agency of Education.

Ms. Saunders’ education experience is largely Florida-based, her most recent job was as chief strategy and innovation officer for Broward County Public Schools, a county that is almost three and a half times the size of Vermont. She was tasked, among other things, with the challenge of figuring out how to close some of the district’s underperforming public schools. Her resume also includes a seven-year stint at Charter Schools USA.

There is no question Ms. Saunders has the intellectual credentials essential to the job. While she may not follow the traditional ladder of past secretaries with their Vermont-based experience, she has a resume replete with innovation-based approaches to educational challenges, something that could be of vital importance to Vermont’s educational system.

That said, Ms. Saunders has become the political target of the progressives who are leery of her charter school background and her present focus on how best to close down schools. They are encouraging the Senate to reject Ms. Saunders’ nomination. Vermont NEA president Don Tunney has sounded the same alarm.

Typically, the governor does not respond in kind, preferring the nomination process to play itself out. It’s exceedingly rare for the Senate to turn down a governor’s nominee for a cabinet position. But the governor has responded, calling the attacks on Ms. Saunders an embarrassment, saying “…all these false accusations and judgments appear to be based on the state she currently lives in, and a cherry-picked part of her resume that’s been turned into a boogeyman with no attempts to understand her work or the value her experience could bring for Vermont kids and schools.”

The governor stepped in because his nomination may be in danger. He needs 15 votes in the Senate where there are only seven Republicans.

What happens next should concern all parties. Education in Vermont is at a crossroads. The Agency of Education has been without a leader for almost a full year and its ranks are depleted. Student population levels have been in a long steady decline. Test scores are less than stellar. We’re staring at a $6 billion price tag for overdue construction needs and we’ve had more than a third of our school districts’ proposed budgets go down to defeat.

Just when we need a fresh dose of confidence about our schools’ future, we have a nominee whose past raises more questions than answers.

The governor can, and should, address the opposition’s concerns by asking Ms. Saunders to clarify her intentions and to point to what she sees as her primary objectives.

First, she should state the obvious which is that Vermont has no charter schools and she has no intention to push the idea here. We are a state comprised almost exclusively of public schools, which is as it should remain.

Second, Vermont has both a cost and a spending issue with its schools. She needs to acknowledge that her first responsibility is to bring clarity to why this is and what can be done to lessen the impact on the state’s taxpayers.

Both points would [or should] soften the opposition’s position on Ms. Saunders’ nomination. The clarification of her position on charter schools is the key consideration for those opposed to her nomination. Put another way, if the governor and Ms. Saunders choose not to make the clarification, then they should not be surprised to see the opposition to her nomination grow.

That would be unfortunate for a state whose educational system needs immediate attention.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here