On December 15, the Commission on the Future of Public Education will release a set of recommendations that, ostensibly, address the state’s growing concern about the performance of its public school system and how it’s funded. The group, established by the Legislature last session, has been meeting since July, but with an understated sense of urgency. One would assume the conversation changed following November’s general election and the Democrats’ loss of their veto-proof majorities in both houses, something they attribute solely to the 14 percent increase in Vermonters’ property taxes.
To that end, Sen. Pro Tempore Philip Baruth has declared school funding a “de facto emergency” and has set aside the first week of the session to the issue and, specifically, to allow Gov. Phil Scott the time and opportunity to say what should be done.
As the various parties begin their maneuvers the Vermont Agency of Education, under the leadership of Interim Secretary of Education Zoie Sanders is beginning to make its presence a factor in the debate. And in a good way. At least for the moment.
The agency is pushing to update the data it has on our schools and our school districts. It’s organized in a way that allows the reader to assess what’s going on school district by school district, region by region, and how we stack up against other states. It eliminates the guessing.
That’s critical if we are to have an informed discussion about our public school system, one that is based on real numbers and real needs. It’s a discussion that needs to happen now and it needs to happen with all sides understanding that while next year’s property tax increase may be less than this year’s 14 percent increase, it’s still likely to be in the high single digits or higher.
Telling the voters they can expect their property taxes to go down is pure sophistry. Not gonna happen.
The value of the agency’s updated data is that we can stop pretending it’s an issue of who pays rather than the educational system itself.
Consider these points:
1. Twenty years ago we had over 93,000 students. As of 2023, that number was a shade over 80,000. The K-12 decline was 21.5 percent, and the decline continues. The drop is more concentrated along the state’s eastern border but it’s a factor statewide. We can’t pretend the trend will reverse itself any time soon.
2. We rank 46th in the size of our schools, yet we rank first in the level of staffing. We rank fifth in the total expenditure per pupil.
3. We rank 11th on our reading proficiency scores, but near the middle on math. We are trending down on our testing scores, which, in many cases reflects how difficult it is for small schools to offer the same educational opportunities.
What’s striking about the agency’s data is the impact of its visuals. Legislators can’t help but notice the difference between regions and between municipalities. Every supervisory union is shown for its strengths and weaknesses. The obvious cannot be ignored.
The more information the agency collects, the more honest the debate before us. That doesn’t make the legislators’ task any easier, but it helps make the debate more honest, and more fruitful. The last thing Vermonters should want is a decision-making process built on the faulty premise that all that is needed is a different payment plan and that all of what we have needs to be kept in place.
The agency’s data makes that clear. It’s now the agency’s responsibility to get it in front of Vermonters.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here