“Don’t tell me what we can’t do. Tell me what we can” is a line that neatly describes the frustration of people who want to get something accomplished but are prevented from doing so because of other people’s choice to simply oppose something, for opposition’s sake.
That frustration was expressed recently by Julie Moore, secretary of the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources, and Kerrick Johnson, commissioner of the Vermont Department of Public Service. They wrote a commentary about Vermont’s housing crisis and called out the state’s environmental organizations for their “reflexive opposition.”
Ms. Moore and Mr. Johnson - two of the state’s most capable leaders - were defending Gov. Phil Scott’s executive order to push forward with some regulatory reforms to speed up the construction of housing projects.
The state’s environmental interest groups were quick to denounce the governor’s efforts. But they offered no alternative. They just said no.
As Ms. Moore and Mr. Johnson wrote in response, “They haven’t proposed how to accelerate permitting while maintaining protections. They haven’t suggested which regulations could be modernized or consolidated. They haven’t identified specific areas where housing could be fast-tracked. Instead, they’ve defaulted to criticism without contribution - the easiest position to maintain and the least helpful for Vermonters struggling to find housing.”
The authors are spot on. What people want is for challenges to be met. What people want is for problems to be solved. And what voters want is a deliberative process that is open and clear. And ultimately, they want to know they have been heard and to see the progress in the form of new homes.
It’s not just one of many issues facing the state. It’s a crisis that underlines all others. We’re 40,000 homes short of where we need to be by 2030. It’s almost impossible to create the prosperity we need if we don’t have homes to house people.
This week, Vermont’s Beta Technologies went public with a higher-than-expected debut of a $1 billion stock offering. CEO Kyle Clark, a native of Chittenden County, was ebullient in his praise of the Vermont-based company and the quality of his 800-person workforce. But he was also careful to point out that the company will need to expand beyond Vermont’s borders.
“We will hit a limit at some point…we have to be a competitive business,” he said. He acknowledged that he had been offered “hundreds of millions of dollars” to move his company elsewhere.
His company faces the same issues other Vermont employers face. They cannot find housing for their employees, and the housing they do find is expensive compared to other states.
Beta is one of Vermont’s fastest-growing, high-wage companies. Its presence in Chittenden and Franklin counties is considered crucial to the prosperity of both.
So when we hear that the governor’s push to build more affordable housing is being opposed by environmental groups, who offer no solutions of their own, it’s more than annoying. It’s a threat to our prosperity that needs to be challenged.
They need to be called out. It’s ridiculous to ask Vermonters to believe that a way can’t be found to protect the environment and to build enough homes to meet our urgent needs.
As Ms. Moore and Mr. Johnson write: “To the environmental goups criticizing this executive order: please show us your plan…if you cannot or will not, then most Vermonters will understand your opposition for what it really is - political theatre performed at the expense of working families searching for places to live and businesses struggling to bring new hires to the state.”
In other words, tell us what we can do, not what we can’t.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here