Don't get into the gutter with a skunk

Posted

On Monday, Gov. Phil Scott received his letter from Pamela Bondi, the nation’s Attorney General, saying Vermont “engages in sanctuary policies and practices that thwart federal immigration enforcement to the detriment of the interests of the United States. This ends now.” Ms. Bondi gave the governor until the next day to respond and to show how Vermont will “eliminate laws, policies, and practices that impede federal immigration enforcement.”

Mr. Scott was even more succinct in Tuesday’s response to Ms. Bondi. He told Ms. Bondi that her “sanctuary jurisdiction” had been made in error. “In fact, the opposite is true. Vermont State law is very clear that the state does not prohibit or impede any public agency from complying with the lawful requirements of 8 U.S.C.1373 and 1644,” he wrote.

Look it up. It’s written in plain English.

“1373: Communication between government agencies and the Immigration and Naturalization Service in general. Notwithstanding any other provision of Federal, State, or local law, a Federal. State or local government entity or official may not prohibit, or in any way restrict, any government entity or official from sending to, or receiving from, the Immigration and Naturalization Service information regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual.”

Vermont’s laws are crystal clear. And the governor even told her he appreciated her letter because it gave him the opportunity to “bring clarity to this situation.”

The governor obviously seized the opportunity to bring a little humor to their relationship. He knows, better than most, that this isn’t about Vermont’s policies, which are clear; it’s about politics. Vermont is not a Trump-friendly state. Our Congressional delegation is Democratic. The vast majority of Vermonters vote Democratic. Our Republican governor doesn’t even like the president, nor did he vote for him.

And the letter to Mr. Scott probably has much less to do with people being in Vermont illegally than with exacting a little revenge from the president. We’re a tiny state. We don’t have many illegals here, and we surely don’t have the big cities and the “bloodthirsty” illegal immigrants that are “terrorizing our cities.”

What we do have is a disproportionate dependency on the dollars we’ve grown to expect from the federal government. For almost a half-century, we had Sen. Patrick Leahy building up the pipeline from Washington to Vermont. Now, we have the fear of President Trump and Ms. Bondi tearing it down.

That’s a key reason Mr. Scott plays nicely when he can. When he was asked for information on SNAP recipients, he did his homework, learned he had no choice but to turn the information over to the federal government, and he did so without being snarky.

In other words, pick your battles.

It’s expected that Vermont’s Attorney General Charity Clark will do most of the state’s legal work against the Trump administration [she’s filed 27 lawsuits against the Trump administration so far. She’s got another three years and four months to go.]

The governor’s path is a little trickier and more consequential. Ms. Bondi made it clear that she’s not confining her efforts to immigration. “…designation as a sanctuary jurisdiction may result in additional consequences and further agency actions as permitted by law.” Take a look at the administration’s battle with Harvard.

That’s our worry. The president has the power to make our lives much more difficult. He could go far beyond immigration issues. He could axe many of the federal government jobs we have. He could make the border issues more difficult. He could cut funding to UVM and to our health care system. And on and on. A court may strike them down - or not - but we could find ourselves in difficult situations that could last a long, long time.

We have a president who is a vengeful man. It’s important for Mr. Scott to be smart in how he picks his battles. It’s the old saw about not getting into the gutter with a skunk.

By Emerson Lynn

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here