The Senate Education Committee Wednesday voted 3-2 to recommend Zoie Saunders to the full Senate as Gov. Phil Scott’s nominee for Vermont’s next education secretary. The Senate is slated to vote on Ms. Saunders’ nomination next week.
It’s expected to be a close vote. The progressives, the VTNEA, and some Democrats are pushing for the nominee to be rejected. There are only seven Republicans in the Senate, meaning the governor has to keep all Republicans and attract nine Democrats to the fold. If it’s a 15-15 vote, then it’s expected Lieutenant Governor David Zuckerman, a progressive, would break the tie, sinking the governor’s nomination. [This assumes all Senators are present, and that the seat of recently retired state senator Dick Mazza, a Democrat, is filled.]
From a purely political perspective, it’s easy to see how Ms. Saunders’ nomination could be in jeopardy. The teachers union is opposed. Most educational organizations have raised serious questions about her lack of public school experience, her past work with charter schools, and her complete lack of familiarity with Vermont’s public school system.
Given the state’s political nature, what is the downside for Democrats/Progressives to oppose her nomination? What are they afraid of? The governor’s popularity? The fear of being dragged down into the educational system’s abyss? The state’s educators, teachers, Democrats, Progressives, etc., are all convinced the Scott administration is opposed to the state’s public education system and has a strong preference for school choice, meaning more independent schools that could take advantage of the state’s town tuitioning system. They think the administration is doing everything within its power to weaken the state’s public school system.
That’s a tightly-held belief and Ms. Saunders’ resume does little to assuage those who worry about the administration’s direction. If so, then why the ambivalence among some Senate Democrats? State Sen. Philip Baruth is president of the Senate and is a UVM English professor and a card-carrying union member - where is his leadership on this key appointment?
The administration is aware of its tenuous position and is fighting back. The governor’s press secretary sent this in an email to Seven Days: “… As the governor has said time and time again, his vision for Vermont, given the substantial investments we are making, is to build the best public education system in the country, from cradle to career, ensuring all of Vermont’s kids have access to success. The status quo simply isn’t delivering that and change is needed. We believe that a vast majority of Vermonters agree.”
That raises more questions than answers, but king among them: What are the changes needed? The Scott administration has been in charge of the educational system since Jan. 5, 2017, and our academic standards have been in a steady decline - why and what needs to change? The costs of running our schools have soared, how did we get where we are and what needs to change?
Those are complicated questions. When the Senate votes on her confirmation next week, senators should be convinced Ms. Saunders understands what’s she facing and how these challenges would be met. Her newness to the state can’t be used as an excuse for delay. We don’t have the time.
The challenges facing Vermont’s educational system are just this side of terrifying. If senators are not convinced Ms. Saunders is equipped for the job, and if she has not convinced them she is a proponent of the state’s public school system, then they should vote no.
That would be a vote of strength, not weakness.
The governor has to own what we see before us; his next term will be his fifth. What’s happening is happening on his watch. Our state senators owe us their due diligence in making sure the challenges facing our schools will be met in a way that strengthens what we have. It’s perhaps the most important leadership decision the Senate will make this session and Vermonters need to know that the path ahead will be one of commitment, shared by all.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here