The University of Vermont Medical Center Thursday said it would cut staff and eliminate medical services in an effort to comply with the Green Mountain Care Board’s order that the hospital cut its costs. The price of health care plans in Vermont has doubled in the last six years. The regulator’s task is to reduce the pace of the increase and UVM's position as the state's largest medical center puts them in the regulator's headlights.
UVM’s medical center has launched a legal battle to overturn the board’s order. In the interim, it has made public the pain involved in meeting the regulator’s financial targets. It’s getting out of the business of kidney transplants, will limit the number of overnight patients, and end the operation of kidney dialysis clinics outside its service area, among other things. The hospital will also eliminate jobs, totaling more than $18 million in reduced payroll costs.
The UVMMC operates on a budget of almost two billion dollars, and it’s the belief of the regulator that there is room within that budget for substantial operating savings, something echoed by the recent Oliver Wyman consultancy report made public this fall.
That may be, but the hospital is making it clear that the retreat will be painful and it intends to take its message to the public.
This hospital versus regulator skirmish will spill over into the Legislature’s lap when the session begins in January. It will be similar to the ongoing debate about how Vermont will deal with its public school system and the taxes required to support it. Both are essential. Both are expensive. Both have the public's attention.
The Legislature’s treatment of both will differ considerably from past sessions. Voters stripped the Democrats of their veto-proof majority and, in the process, sent a clear message that they wanted their costs reduced. The election was a dramatic turnaround for both parties; Democrats were chastened, Republicans emboldened. The message: Don’t end the session without some meaningful cost reductions.
Gov. Phil Scott expressed his exasperation last year when he told Democratic legislators his opinion didn’t mean much since they had the votes to do as they wished, a sentiment Democrats carried out with the overriding of his vetoes and the dismissal of the governor’s concern about the 14 percent hike in property taxes. They were also solid in their belief that the voters were sympathetic to their legislative agenda, high costs, and all.
It has been almost forever since a political party in Vermont has been so wrong.
If Democrats double down on their agenda, pushing costs higher, they will most likely lose again. Vermonters are at that point. They want the focus to be on not only the quality of services but their costs.
That is the dilemma. To attract growth requires having a high-quality healthcare system and good public schools. To keep voters happy requires having both systems be affordable. That’s the needle that both the governor and legislators must thread.
The heavy part of the lift is accepting that the Vermont of decades past isn’t the Vermont we have today. We have too many schools for the population we have. Our student population rate continues to decline, and our student-to-teacher ratio is too small. This decline affects our healthcare system as well. The patient population is older, sicke,r and more expensive to treat. The healthcare infrastructure of the past may be less relevant to today’s demographics.
The question is whether legislators - of both parties - are able to resist the political temptation to keep all things as they are, to protect their own, unwilling to ask school districts and our healthcare system to be open to change.
What should be painfully clear is that acceptance of the status quo has come to a screeching halt. Legislators will need to show they heard them.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here