With a little less than a month remaining in the legislative session, legislators are reaching for the panic button, wondering if Gov. Phil Scott will hold to his promise of refusing to sign the budget if the Legislature doesn’t pass an educational reform bill that meets his expectations.
The public tends to dismiss such threats, treating them like political theater. It’s never happened, so why should anyone think it will happen now? Besides, we’ve managed to survive the government shutdowns at the federal level; wouldn’t managing a shutdown from Montpelier be a less threatening exercise?
Well, according to the Legislature’s Joint Fiscal Office, no. Unlike the federal government, the State is not authorized to spend “any” money from the state Treasury without an enacted budget. This includes state employees, schools, vendors and contractors, and grant recipients.
Because the state’s Constitution is so clear, it’s never happened. Mr. Scott threatened to do the same in his first term when he vetoed two state budgets in 2018. With less than two days before the end of the fiscal year, June 30, he allowed the budget to become law absent his signature.
The cost of slamming the brakes on state spending wasn’t worth the political cost.
But, five terms later, soaring poll numbers, and an educational system that is both broken and unduly expensive, Mr. Scott believes it’s his responsibility to force the Legislature to pass an educational reform bill that meets his expectations.
The Legislature - controlled by the Democrats - agrees that the educational system needs tending, but rejects the governor’s proposal to cut costs by consolidating the state’s 119 school districts into five districts. In fact, the House has rejected the idea of mandatory consolidation at any level.
The governor shows no sign of retreat. He was quoted in a Vermont Public story saying the Legislature had the responsibility to pass legislation that conformed to Act 73, the educational reform bill passed last year. He called on legislators to “Have the will and the courage to move forward and do what’s right for the state of Vermont. We can get this done. We can get this done in a week…Shame on them if they let it go two months without coming up with a solution.”
Senate Pro Tempore Phil Baruth doesn’t believe the governor would ever shut the government down. He says the governor caved in 2018 and will cave again if Democrats don’t acquiesce to his demands. In other words, he says not to worry about it.
Maybe.
But after five terms in office and his continued inability to make much progress in reforming our school system and battling back against a ruinous series of property tax hikes, why wouldn’t he be anxious to exercise some political muscle? Why wouldn’t he be reluctant to end the session, having to tell Vermonters that we’re further behind now than we were a year ago when Act 73 was passed?
Mr. Baruth says there is enough time remaining in the session for the House and Senate to “agree on something and the governor can join in.”
If so, it’s the Senate that will need to exercise the leadership, as it has done before. The Senate has already set itself apart from the House by agreeing with the governor that the state surplus of $105 million should be used to “buy down” the property tax rate to four percent. The House had voted to use only half the surplus, thus pushing the property tax rate increase up to seven percent.
The Senate’s position is just election-year common sense. The last thing Democrats need is a repeat of 2024 when the property tax/school cost debate cost them their veto-proof majorities.
That wound remains. We’ve also entered a time when it’s not unexpected for those in power to test the limits of what’s been acceptable or the norm. The Trump administration can be defined by that practice.
At the same time, we must recognize that people tire of the same complaints. They tire of the same problems, never seeing any steps forward toward their resolution. The difference between 2018 and 2026 for Mr. Scott is that he’s as tired of failure as his constituents. He’s not in his first term; he’s in his fifth and going for his sixth. His patience has worn thin, as has the patience of Vermonters.
It may be a mistake for Democrats to doubt him.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here