Dems may have weaker case than they think

Posted

As of Wednesday at 12:01 a.m., the government ran out of money. And the financial markets piddled along as if nothing had happened. Most of us did the same. Been there, done that. It’s an insider’s game with both political parties angling for their perceived advantages. Meanwhile, most Americans wonder how it is that we’ve elected adults to conduct themselves in a way that prioritizes the value of the fight over the importance of keeping the ship of state upright.

And how hard could it be to agree to keep the government funded at roughly its present level of spending? 

But here we are. And no one can claim with any sense of believability that they know what will happen next. Republicans believe the public will blame the Democrats because they are the ones who refused to agree to any likely path forward to keep the government running. Democrats believe they have the edge by hanging everything on the need to keep intact the Biden-era health care subsidies. Democrats, particularly the far left, also resolved not to accommodate the Republicans at any level. 

The outcome will depend on how long the standoff lasts. The last standoff - in President Trump’s first term in 2019 - lasted 35 days. Mr. Trump bragged about how he would force Congressional Democrats to cough up the money to build his wall. But, as we know, he caved and didn’t get a cent.

The Democratic Party’s far left may be walking into the same sort of trap with this week’s shutdown. Republicans may eventually agree to partially restore the pandemic-era subsidies, but absolutely not to the level desired by the Democratic Party’s activists. And let’s hope so. The Biden-era subsidies are overly generous. The healthcare subsidies cover people up to 400 percent of the poverty line. It would cost taxpayers $450 billion over the next decade to keep them in place. 

The public already has a dim view of the Democratic Party’s liberals and their penchant for overspending, and, in general, for ignoring the issues that beset middle America, issues like crime, a softening job market, and the cost of living. 

In other words, Democrats are entering the shutdown in a position of weakness, thinking their one-issue stand will prevail. This weakness should give the Democrats pause, given that the mid-term elections are little more than a year away.

It won’t be much of a trick for Republicans to point out that Democrats are asking them to agree to the $450 billion spending increase that Democrats refused to support in 2021 when they had the votes to get it passed.

Democrats should also come to terms with the fact that the first priority of most Americans is to figure out how to make their dollar go further. As most economists acknowledge, President Biden’s $1.9 trillion covid spending bill gave us the worst inflation in more than 40 years. We’re still mid-battle, which is why the Federal Reserve has been slow in reducing rates - much to the president’s chagrin.

Whereas Americans who have their health care subsidized want every benefit they can get, it doesn’t make economic sense for households with six-figure incomes to be subsidized by the rest of us. The program was sold to the American people as temporary relief. That’s not what the Democrats are arguing for now, and that’s a mistake.

If the Democrats refuse to negotiate their differences, there is a chance that the president and his party will make mistakes of their own. You don’t have to be a genius to figure out that President Trump will pick people, programs, and places that hurt Democrats specifically and help Republicans. There is every chance the Republicans will push too long and too hard, as is the inclination of their party’s far right.

But, if the battle boils down to protecting health care subsidies as currently subsidized, the Democrats have a weak case.

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here