Dems lost this issue once, why try again

Posted

If Vermont’s voters read only the headline, the November general election may be a tough one for the Democrats, who could, once again, be tarred with the “raising taxes” brush. And it would be a self-inflicted wound.

The House voted on Thursday to raise property taxes by seven percent to pay for the operation of our schools. That was in opposition to Gov. Phil Scott’s proposal, which would have held the increase to four percent. 

The difference between the House bill and what Mr. Scott proposed is how the state’s $105 million surplus is used. The governor wants the entire $105 million devoted to reducing the property tax, hence the four percent figure. The House proposal cuts that in half, preferring to save $50 million for next year, when, once again, there will be a need to “buy down” next year’s tax increase.

The governor’s contention is two-fold; first, there’s no guarantee that the Legislature would use the $50 million to reduce taxes next year, and, second, Vermonters can’t afford to have their property taxes increased by seven percent. Rates have increased 40 percent over the last five years, and adding another seven percent - particularly in this fiscal environment - is a showstopper for most taxpayers.

There was also the hope that the run-up in educational costs would spur the Legislature to pass legislation that would rein in school costs, thus putting the brake on future property tax increases. 

That may happen, but the odds are less than favorable, and whatever legislation might pass is not likely to affect next year’s schools’ costs.

Still, House Democrats are to be partially excused for their support of this week’s bill.  If the entire $105 million surplus were used this year, then next year’s fiscal cliff gets that much steeper, something they have noted. Most of Vermont’s schools are struggling to find strategies to handle future increases in health care costs, contract agreements with their unions, and the normal pressures of inflation, which, thanks to the war in Iran, will be significantly higher than forecast at the session’s beginning. The Dems were looking for an easier path forward to handle next year’s budget challenges.

The Democrats are sounding a cautionary alarm and trying to find their own path forward, not conceding to the governor.  Mr. Scott’s plan also hides the true cost of education, and it basically builds in a double-digit hike next year. The Democrats argue that’s not a responsible course of action.

Argument accepted.

If that is the path the Democrats choose, they had better improve their strategy when explaining their choice to the voters. Asking voters to “trust them” that the $50 million will be safely tucked away to be used next year is a big political risk. And telling the voters that they are better off getting less rather than more is a tough political sell, to put it mildly.

The Democrats have been down this road once before, and they lost. Big time. Why are they going down the same road again?

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here