When the Legislature convened in early January, it was clear that the session’s primary task was to cobble together a bill that would reduce Vermont’s educational costs and provide paths to a reconfigured system that would raise Vermont’s flagging academic standards. It was to be an improved version of last year’s Act 73.
That won’t happen if the bill passed out of the House Education Committee this week is the best they can do. Gov. Phil Scott has made it clear he expects the Legislature to be bolder, less squimish about making tough choices, and quicker to put a plan into place, not delaying for years on end, or allowing all district consolidations to be voluntary. And, separately, he also wants the Legislature to buy down the property tax from 10 percent to four percent. He’s opposed to the Democrats’ proposal to only use half the $105 million surplus, thus forcing a seven percent increase in the property tax.
The Democrats are not wrong with many of their choices. There is no way Vermonters will accept the governor’s proposal to consolidate the state’s 119 school districts down to five. And the Dems are leery about any changes that rid school districts of their local control. They also don’t want to use all of the state’s surplus to achieve the governor’s four percent property tax increase. They think it’s wiser to keep $50 million of the surplus for use next year, thus avoiding part of next year’s expected property tax increase.
It’s a given the House bill will not survive in its present form. Substantial compromises will need to be made with the administration before the governor has anything he’s willing to sign into law. The governor is pushing for school district consolidation mandates. The House bill completely abandons forced school district mergers.
Basically, the administration contends that nothing happens if all decisions are voluntary. Communities will opt to keep things as they are, as we’ve seen with several school districts that have refused to change, no matter the common sense involved.
It’s an election year, and the governor now has some competition. It’s a given that reform of our educational system will be central to the campaign. Both parties understand this. The Dems, at this point, are positioning themselves as being the least contentious, arguing that they are giving school districts and their voters the tools to make their own decisions.
The governor can point to the futility of a plan that gives everyone the chance to say no and a plan that won’t produce any results for years. And he can - and will - beat up on the Dems for backing the proposal to raise Vermonters’ property tax bill to seven percent, instead of his four percent proposal.
At this point, the advantage goes to the governor. His message is clear, and it’s simple: the Dems’ plan won’t work, it’s weak, it saves no money anytime soon, and, separately, they are raising people’s property tax bills by seven percent.
The Dems don’t have a good response to the governor. They don’t have the votes to override the governor’s veto. Nor do they want to end the session with nothing to show for it.
Given the weakness of the Dems’ legislative leadership, it would behoove the rank and file to start figuring out how and where to compromise with the governor. The ed bill touches the pocketbook of every Vermonter. No one is better at making that point clear than the governor. The Dems have a weak hand; they’d better figure out how to strengthen it.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here