Eight members of the Senate Democratic caucus broke ranks to side with Republicans to end the longest government shutdown in the nation’s history. All eight were moderates, and all eight do not face reelection campaigns. All eight saw no hope that Republicans would capitulate and agree to extend the Affordable Care Act subsidies. All eight saw the growing pain of the shutdown to be more than the public should have to bear.
The moderates’ decision has invited the recrimination of the Democrats’ left wing. Vermont’s Sen. Bernie Sanders said Sunday night, “…eight Democrats voted with Republicans. To my mind, this was a very, very bad vote.”
Mr. Sanders’ response is hardly surprising. Arguably, he would have opposed any agreement reached with Republicans unless it guaranteed a continuation of the ACA subsidies at current or higher levels.
That wasn’t going to happen. And it shouldn’t. The Affordable Care Act - Obamacare - while crucial, would cost an estimated $450 billion over the next decade. A third of the recipients have household incomes 400 percent above the federal poverty level. There is no reason for taxpayers to be subsidizing high-income families.
That said, there is every reason to subsidize families on the middle and low end of the income scale. In a Vermont Public story this week, there was the example of a single, middle-income individual who was paying $73 a month for her health insurance and being told the price would jump to $1,636 a month. Her deductible was raised to $15,000.
That’s essentially a no-insurance plan.
The Republican leadership has agreed to a floor vote in December to extend the Obamacare tax credits. Democrats also get to decide which bill the extension would be attached to - not a small consideration.
The proposal also deals with the SNAP food assistance program, which helps one out of every eight Americans. It also funds the Department of Agriculture and the FDA, military construction projects, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and basically the operation of Congress for the remainder of the current fiscal year. The remaining agencies would be funded through January 30, 2026.
The odds of the bill being approved would seem decent. It’s hard to imagine allowing the shutdown to extend through the holidays. Thanksgiving is 16 days away. Christmas is six weeks away.
The polls show that most Americans are opposed to the shutdown and want their representatives back at work. They want the pain that’s being inflicted to stop. That’s the message the Senate’s Democratic moderates delivered.
Contrary to Mr. Sanders’ belief, there is no reason to think that Democrats have forfeited the inertia of last week’s election. It’s just the opposite; the health care debate needs its own stage. Whereas the ACA needs to be structured in a way that is more fiscally reasonable, allowing it to expire, and exposing tens of millions of Americans to prohibitively expensive health care plans is not acceptable.
That political accountability is more easily achieved if there is an up-and-down vote on healthcare as a single issue rather than having it part of the omnibus package being considered to end the government shutdown.
Mr. Sanders wants the fight to continue and for the government to remain closed unless the healthcare issue is solved to his satisfaction, which would never happen. Fortunately, the party’s moderates are more in line with the American public, who want their government back at work. And they are smart enough to know that the fight continues. Maybe Mr. Sanders and his ilk will thank them later.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here