Dealing with education, next up is healthcare

Posted

Vermont’s healthcare premiums are the nation’s highest, almost double the national average. For the last decade, our premium increases have averaged 10 percent, meaning Vermonters have seen their healthcare premiums double. Here is the bad news: they are heading skyward again.

BlueCross BlueShieldVT, the state’s largest insurer, said this week that 2024 was a miserable year financially. The company lost a staggering $62 million. Over the last four years, the losses total $149 million. The company, which covers over 220,000 Vermonters, says it will need to ask the Green Mountain Care Board for another 15 percent increase, at a minimum.

A spokesman for the insurer attributed the loss to “extraordinary prices at our hospitals” and rising demand for costly services, including “GLP-1s”, which includes weight-loss drugs.

In an op-ed elsewhere on this page, Northwestern Medical Center CEO Peter Wright makes the point that it’s not enough to accept superficial answers to complicated questions when it comes to healthcare. We need to dig deeper into questions of why healthcare costs are rising, and what tools we have available to mitigate costs.

The questions apply to BCBSVT as well. In October 2023, it finalized its merger with the much larger BlueCross BlueShield of Michigan. The merger was sold as one that would benefit Vermont. The combination was supposed to leverage larger discounts from pharmaceutical companies, which would lower our drug costs. We would have access to technology that would streamline our operations. Overall, it was advertised as a way for Vermont’s small operation to benefit from Michigan’s much larger membership [over five million.]

So, how has Vermont’s BCBS operation benefited from the merger? How has Vermont’s BCBS membership benefited? To be sure, Michigan’s BCBS membership has not suffered anywhere close to the percentage increases levied against Vermont’s members. Vermont’s operation also had to borrow $30 million from the Michigan operation, which it will have to repay along with an eight percent interest rate, which is hardly a bargain. [It’s also another built-in expense, something that will add to BCBSVT’s need to raise its premiums.]

It may be that without the merger BCBSVT would be out of business. The GMCB last year allowed BCBSVT to raise its individual premiums by 19.8 percent and small group premiums by 22.8 percent to keep the business’s doors open. Is that to be the case this year? How can it not be?

When Vermonters were told their property taxes would go up by 14 percent last year they reacted by defeating more than a third of the state’s school budgets. The increase also cost the Democrats their veto-proof majorities in both houses. But it also spurred the governor - and our legislators - to become more serious about reworking how education is delivered in Vermont, and at what cost.

But Vermonters spend far more on healthcare than they do on education. So when do we start paying serious attention to the whys and wherefores of what it costs to deliver health care in Vermont? When do we begin paying attention to the forces identified in the Oliver-Wyman report on our hospitals, noting that the majority of our hospitals are operating in the red, that things need to change?

As Mr. Wright explains, some of the math isn’t complicated. It’s “rate times volume.” He also notes that NMC’s rate has been limited to an average of 3.87 percent since 2011, which is far below the rate of inflation for health care. Demand - or volume - has increased markedly. He also brought to our attention that the average Vermonter is “11 percent sicker now than a decade ago.”

That’s a mind-blowing statistic. Why are we that much sicker in ten years? Why is it, for example, that the people of Maine pay half what we do in healthcare premiums and they have the same, or worse, demographics? Why is the monthly cost for our lowest cost commercial insurance plan a little over $800 and the same plan costs roughly $275 in New Hampshire?

Vermont can’t sell itself as a place to live and work if it continues to outpace all other states for the cost of something as vital as our healthcare. The work has begun to address the work that needs to be done to deal with property taxes and the cost of education. That needs to happen with healthcare. And it needs to happen now.

Mr. Wright is correct: We need to get behind the headlines to understand what’s happening before we can deal with it. That will be an uncomfortable process. It means change. 

With our schools, it took a political upheaval to begin the process. Doesn’t yet another double-digit increase in our healthcare premiums qualify?

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here