Dairy and the loss of 600 jobs

Posted

With the eventual closing of Perrigo, the baby formula maker in Georgia, Franklin Foods, the maker of cream cheese located in Enosburg, and the “idling” of the St. Albans Cooperative Creamery on Federal Street, the county is facing the loss of roughly 600 jobs, a significant blow to the county’s economy.

The bulk of the job losses comes from the loss of 420 jobs at Perrigo, which decided a year or so ago that it was a more profitable choice to move its production to newer plants rather than upgrade the Georgia facility. It wasn’t a failure on anyone’s part locally. The focus of publicly traded companies like Perrigo is on the bottom line.

The good news is that the unemployment rate in Chittenden County is 2.2 percent, with Franklin County’s rate pegged at 2.5 percent. Companies are still eager to fill their rosters; the 420 Perrigo employees should have a decent chance of finding employment, given their proximity to Chittenden County and St. Albans. Still, the Town of Georgia will lose revenue from the plant’s closure, and employees will likely travel farther for their next job.

Enosburg’s loss has a silver lining. A new company, Franklin County Cheese, reportedly will take over operations soon, albeit at a 20-employee level, a 70-person loss to the community. Locals are crossing their fingers that the new business takes root and flourishes.

The biggest story is the announcement by Dairy Farmers of America to “idle” its facility on Federal Street. It was a short time ago - August 1, 2019 - that the coop’s 300 farmers voted overwhelmingly to sell and merge with the national giant. Franklin County farmers had been hit hard by a long string of low milk prices, and the coop needed cash for upgrades to its aging facility. If it is shut down, almost 100 jobs will disappear with it.

It’s part of the story of the dairy industry’s decline - not in the amount of milk produced, but in the number of farms and the continuing drive to find operating efficiencies. A half-century ago, we had roughly 500-600 dairy farms in Franklin County. That number dropped to about 300 at the turn of the century, and today, there are roughly 90 operating dairy farms. We still produce roughly the same amount of milk, but we just do it with much larger farms.

Despite that precipitous drop in the number of farms, it still defines us in large part. It’s our history and our culture. It’s what keeps our land open and the tourists coming. It’s still a big part of our economic numbers. Being the “dairy capital” of New England means we generate over 25 percent of the state’s agricultural sales and drive a regional gross domestic product of over $600 million annually. That’s not peanuts.

There is also the supply chain beyond the farm gate, which is key to the health of our local economies. Few do more than our farmers in supporting feed and fertilizer dealers, vets, truck drivers, hardware stores, and independent processing facilities.

We don’t know yet what the impact will be on our remaining Franklin County farmers who are DFA members. The expectation is that DFA will transport the milk to other larger processing plants. If so, that is likely to increase our farmers’ costs, which makes their lives just that much more difficult. As if our farmers need a higher bar to climb. There is also the push to get farmers to focus more on marketing their own milk rather than simply shipping it off to another state’s processing plant. That’s easier said than done. Like many other industries, the dairy industry rewards scale, i.e., mega farms, mega-processors, and distribution networks that stretch from one end of the country to the other.

The mission now is to protect and support what we have. Most important is to keep diversifying our economy so we can stay ahead of its changing nature. Franklin County has one of the strongest manufacturing sectors in the state. It’s crucial to maintain and then to build upon it. The economic model that has sustained us for generations continues to change. But there are new opportunities in specialty food manufacturing, value-added dairy products, ag technology, and entrepreneurship. We just have to reimagine our roles, much like the City of St. Albans has done with its downtown revitalization. We have to leverage our agricultural heritage in ways that embrace new ideas and new markets.

We’ve done it before.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here