The critics of local economic development efforts habitually point out that the development would have happened anyway and that spending taxpayer dollars on such development is a waste. Nothing could be further from the truth, and no city offers a better refutation than the City of St. Albans and its efforts over the past decade.
Those efforts continued this month when the St. Albans City Council extended a $350,000 grant to Adam Monette and his business partner to facilitate the opening of a new restaurant in the Congress & Main Building. [It’s expected to open in September.]
The grant is an extension of the city’s practice to help downtown businesses overcome the high costs of opening shop. The need was explained by City Manager Dominic Cloud: “We find that in our downtowns there’s a gap, a market failure where new businesses can’t cover the cost of fit up and the landlord can’t absorb them without increasing their rent, and so projects die. We’re responding to that using some of the ARPA funds to address this failure.”
The city has been the force behind similar efforts and has offered like amounts of money. It’s been the difference between storefronts being empty or occupied. This renovation of downtown would not have happened otherwise.
The city is also part owner of the Congress & Main building and $300,000 of the $350,000 is being used to upgrade the building’s infrastructure, to make it suitable for retail. In other words, the city is investing in itself. Which is smart. Keep in mind that the city’s investment in the Congress & Main projects has resulted in a $9 million increase in the city’s grand list, which helps moderate the taxpayer’s tax bills.
What’s important to recognize is that helping businesses open their doors is not a single-item strategy for revitalizing downtown. The larger role is figuring out how to draw more traffic downtown so that businesses survive. That’s the city’s purpose in building “workforce” housing downtown and on Lower Newton. The more people we have living downtown, the more people we have frequenting our stores.
It’s a complimentary strategy that has been in place from the outset. It’s the reason the state office building was relocated to Federal Street. It’s the reason for the city’s downtown garage. It’s the reason for the Hampton Inn on Lake Street. It’s the reason the city is fighting so hard to maintain the U.S. Passport office on South Main and why the city lured the Community College of Vermont to relocate to the Congress & Main building.
It’s all about traffic. One supports the other.
Adam Monette’s restaurant is part of that strategy. He captured national attention in 2021 when he won the Food Network’s Holiday Baking Championship. He has some star power that should attract interest from area foodies. That increased traffic will help other restaurants and stores as well [which explains why fast food places always build next to one another; it’s about the traffic.]
There isn’t anything simple about small cities rebuilding their downtowns. Particularly in Vermont. We’re small and don’t have a lot of extra cash, which is why the city has always stressed the need for a public-private partnership. It’s that partnership, along with the advantages of the Tax Increment Financing [TIF], that continues to sustain the city’s ongoing effort to keep its revitalization efforts so vibrant. It’s why the city’s grand list is on track to hit an additional $100 million, courtesy of the TIF, and why the city’s voters have been so supportive of the council’s direction. Everyone - including the the taxpayers - benefits.
The city council was wise to continue reinvesting in itself, with Mr. Monette’s restaurant being a partial beneficiary. It’s a practice that’s proven successful for over a decade and it’s a success that would never have happened on its own.
Don’t let the critics suggest otherwise.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here