Congress should make itself part of the discussion

Posted

Isolationists from the far right of the Republican Party and liberals from the Democratic Party’s left wing, have something in common: they share an antipathy for fights beyond our shores. Our struggles at home warrant all our time and resources. Nowhere else.

Vermont’s Sen. Bernie Sanders believes that, and took it a step further on Sunday. Upon hearing about President Donald Trump’s decision to bomb Iran’s nuclear facilities he said, “We cannot allow ourselves to be dragged into another Middle East war based on lies.”

Mr. Sanders then added Trump’s decision to bomb Iran to a list of lies told by our politicians that led to military actions resulting in the deaths of American troops that added nothing to the nation’s security.

“In the 1960s the United States government lied to the American people and took us into a terrible war in Vietnam.

“The United States invaded Iraq and became embroiled in a long civil war there. No weapons of mass destruction were ever found. That war was based on a lie - a lie which cost us 4.492 young Americans…

“The American people are being lied to again today. We cannot allow history to repeat itself,” Mr. Sanders said.

But what is not being repeated, and should have been, is the fact that Congress gave permission to President Lyndon Baines Johnson to commit our troops to the war in Viet Nam and Congress gave its approval to George W. Bush to enter into war with Iraq. Congress was constitutionally obligated to give its approval.

That didn’t happen before Sunday’s attack. The administration defended its decision to exclude Congress by saying it was a limited action in response to a threat to the nation’s defense. That President Trump would opt to decide for himself and not wait for Congress to debate the merits should not surprise anyone.

But Mr. Sanders' effort to conflate the need for Congress to give the president permission to attack Iraq and the claim that the president based his actions upon a web of lies to the American people is wrong, and not comparable to the circumstances that got us into the war in Viet Nam or Iraq. It's a tautological argument that weakens his premise.

The world knows Iran has the capability of building nuclear weapons. The world knows it has deceived the International Atomic Energy Agency, whose job it is to monitor Iran’s nuclear programs. The world knows that Iran is the leading state sponsor of terrorism and was the power behind the throne for Hamas and for the governments of Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, and, Yeman. We know that it wants to annihilate Israel. We know that its allies are North Korea, China, and Russia. We know the United States is its sworn enemy. And we know that if Iran were allowed to develop a nuclear bomb it would set off an arms race in the Middle East and beyond.

We also know every president for the last two decades and beyond has embraced the same belief, which is that the world would be a much safer place without Iran and its nuclear weapons. President Trump has at least acted on that need.

What happens next is unknown. But the war with Israel and the U.S. bombings have left Iran in a much weaker position than it’s been in recent memory. It should be obvious this president has no reluctance to do what’s necessary to slay the nuclear dragon. That’s something that the world’s dictatorships - Russia, China, and North Korea - will duly note. And, perhaps our NATO allies.

If there is a hopeful outcome it would be that Iran would see the futility of its course and agree to scrap its nuclear weapons capability. If that were to happen, Iran and its Persian Gulf allies would likely see their economies improve dramatically. The Islamic revolution that began in 1979 might begin to dissolve and the Middle East would cease being the world’s tinder box,

It’s a long shot. But it carries more hope than sitting on the sidelines with our fingers in our ears, thinking the problem will solve itself and that the world will be safer for it.

That said, Congress should take the steps necessary to become part of the deliberative process. Surely they can't believe there is not more to follow.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here