Committee's ruling hurts Vt.'s housing needs

Posted

Voltaire wrote that “Every man is guilty of all the good he did not do.” That’s so appropriate in response to the Legislative Committee on Administrative Rules [LCAR] decision on Thursday to reject the Scott administration’s proposed changes in wetland development rules, changes that would affect a tiny portion of the state’s wetlands, yet significantly address the state’s housing crisis.

The committee’s choice was to do nothing that would help us build homes; in fact, their position was an argument in favor of limiting choice and continuing the environmental overreach that has contributed so profoundly to our high housing costs and lack of availability.

The governor’s executive order was intended to direct state agencies to reduce barriers to housing construction, especially in designated growth areas. Specifically, he wanted to target what he calls Vermont’s overly regulated wetlands permitting system. The wetland regulations slow housing construction, add costs and uncertainty, and require site-by-site wetland reviews, which are expensive and time-consuming. 

The governor’s push included a change from 50 feet to 25 feet in the distance from the identified wetland to the home being built. He also wanted to substitute aerial mapping of wetlands in place of the need to hire someone to visit the site in person. There’s nothing seismic about any of the governor’s proposals.

The LCAR decision ruled against the governor on all accounts, saying basically that he acted beyond the scope of the law, which holds that “the goal of wetlands regulation and management in the State is the net gain of wetlands to be achieved through protection of existing wetlands and restoration of wetlands that were previously adversely affected.”

The governor’s proposal makes it clear that only two to three percent of the land in question would be affected. Miro Weinberger, executive chair of Let’s Build Homes, made his organization’s reaction clear: “What do we value more: protecting every inch of unmapped wetlands in the two to three percent of Vermont designated for housing development [at a time when our wetland maps have dramatically improved in accuracy], or putting more Vermonters into desperately needed homes at prices they can actually afford?”

Most Vermonters would agree - without hesitation - that the governor’s ask is a small one. Vermont is desperate for more housing. We’re about 40,000 homes shy of where we need to be, and the lack of housing that’s affordable is a major contributor to our lack of affordability on many fronts.

The session has been labeled by a business organization as “The Great Correction,” signifying the Legislature’s willingness to pull back on earlier environmental and Act 250 land-use reforms. That distinction is motivated in part by the political reality of the Democratic Party, which continues to struggle to find ways to deal with the state’s issues without bankrupting it. 

Clearly, the LCAR didn’t get the message. It had the opportunity to do some good. It chose not to, and if the committee’s stand prevails, it’s very likely that the voters in November will hold them responsible. And they should.

By Emerson Lynn

  

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here