City Council should approve landlord policy

Posted

The St. Albans City Council has before it a proposed “rental registry policy” that would help address the city’s public safety issues and protect the $100 million investment in its decade-long downtown revitalization effort. The proposed policy is overdue and one the council should embrace.

As explained by Messenger reporter Josh Ellerbrock, the proposed policy would hold landlords accountable for the behavior of their tenants, or what happens in the properties they rent. The definition being considered is: “Properties where the police are repeatedly called for disorderly conduct, assault, larceny investigations, illicit drug use, noise, and disturbance of the peace may be public nuisances that threaten the public health, safety, and/or welfare.”

The proposed ordinance isn’t intended to harass landlords, most of whom are responsible. It’s being drafted with the help of councilor Tim Hawkins, who is a lawyer, and often represents landlords. He supports the idea because it could give landlords the tools to avoid having their properties become “public nuisances.”

Under the proposed statute landlords would need to have at least two incidents filed against them over a 90-day period before there was an actionable issue. As City Manager Dominic Cloud explained, even then any discipline against them would likely be dropped if the landlord showed any intent to correct the behavior. If not, the landlord would not only have to appear before the council but could be fined $800 per infraction.

That’s a pretty low bar for a landlord. The proposed statute serves as an incentive for landlords to be aware of their tenants’ behavior, and to use the statute as the legal means to correct the behaviors if necessary. If they make the effort, the fines disappear.

The proposed policy will have its critics. We have landlords who generally oppose any interference in how they conduct their business. Fair enough. But landlords should also be mindful of the impact “bad actors” can have on those around them, including next-door neighbors, the neighborhood, and the city. Giving these bad actors a free pass doesn’t work. It makes the city a less safe place to be.

Why would we countenance that?

The proposed policy will go before the council at least two additional times before any conclusive action is taken. Along the way there will be some word-smithing to answer questions and to fill in the details. It’s important to make the new policy as bullet-proof as it can be made. It’s almost a given that groups such as the ACLU, etc., will take umbrage with the proposal, arguing that such a policy could force landlords to push tenants out of their apartments and onto the streets.

So, the answer is to not address the public safety issue that exists, to allow the very, very few to disrupt life for the many? Is it okay for a landlord to have rentals to which the police are repeatedly called for assaults, drug use, noise, and behavior that threatens the public’s safety and health?

The 300 or so people who attended the public safety meeting at city hall last summer have a clear answer to those questions. It would be a hard no. Full stop. 

The public’s safety is the city’s primary obligation. Ensuring it is in the city’s best interest. We should be diligent in our efforts to protect and preserve all the good we’ve accomplished with our TIF-based revitalization efforts. Asking the city’s landlords to be part of that mission is not an unreasonable ask. It’s actually in their best interest.

Councilor Trudy Cioffi is right when she said, “I think we have to try it, just to see how it goes. I think we have to do something.”

The council should move forward with the proposed rental registry policy; it’s a given they have the community’s support. The city has restored itself, the council should be willing to protect that progress and not allow others to pick it apart.

By Emerson Lynn 

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here