The annual meeting of the Vermont Bar Association is a pedestrian affair if there ever was one. Achingly quotidian. This year’s meeting was the exception. Every Vermonter should be thankful.
Vermont Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Reiber stood before his colleagues and told them our constitutional democracy was being threatened by President Donald Trump. Mr. Trump was attacking the rule of law's foundation.
“Currently, it appears there is an effort in Washington, D.C. to destroy the public’s faith in the courts, in our system of justice, in this country … The president, through a series of executive orders, seeks to erect barriers to lawyers who represent clients who disagree with him. No prior administration has taken such concerted action against the bar, an effort to erode an institutional pillar designed to check abuse of power,” Mr. Reiber said.
Josh Diamond, president of the Vermont Bar Association’s board of managers, said it was a “historic moment” to have the chief justice express his concerns and to have the members embrace it.
A petition signed by over 200 Vermont lawyers and elected officials was put together that specifically noted 15 instances in which the Trump administration took illegal actions showing its “disdain for the rule of law.”
A rally on behalf of the lawyers, and their concerns, has been organized by Natalie Silver, a Burlington lawyer, for May 3. Again, that has to be a first. A rally organized by lawyers for lawyers?
But few things could be more important. As Founding Father John Adams observed, our republic is a “government of laws, not of men.” He was fearful of aristocrats with their inherited titles and privileges, leaders who governed through fear and intimidation. Like Mr. Trump.
Lose the rule of law and we lose our democracy.
Of particular concern to Mr. Reiber is the president’s assault on the legal profession’s independence. Mr. Trump's target has been law firms who dare to represent those inclined to litigate against the federal government or against any of Mr. Trump’s interests, or those who would limit his vengeance.
The reason Vermont’s legal profession is so concerned is that Mr. Trump’s intimidation has worked. His executive orders have imposed sanctions on those “offending” law firms by lifting security clearances for their lawyers, forbidding them to handle any government business, and targeting the firms' pro bono work for groups not sympathetic to the administration’s beliefs. The president has ordered the Attorney General to review all suits filed against the federal government over the past eight years, the intent being to silence or sanction those firms hostile to Mr. Trump's agenda.
Several of the largest law firms have acquiesced, even agreeing to toss in millions of dollars in pro bono work for the president’s pet causes. They acquiesced because they did the math; they would lose a lot of money if they didn’t.
Some have fought back, defending their First Amendment rights and understanding how imperative it is to oppose such unlawful assaults on the profession’s independence. And it’s to those that Chief Justice Reiber was speaking.
But it’s an issue bigger than President Trump’s illegal assault. If Mr. Trump prevails, there is no reason to believe the next president will not do the same. The left can be just as extreme as the right, given the cause.
That’s the importance of Mr. Reiber's effort to take on the president and to remind the rest of his profession [and Vermonters] that this is not a challenge to be dismissed or an idle thought to be cast aside.
The judiciary is one of our three branches of government. As Chief Justice Reiber argues, it's time the legal profession rises to its constitutional calling.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here