When we are told that Vermont has far and away the highest healthcare costs - something easily verifiable - the medical establishment is quick to explain why. Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement payments are too low, forcing hospitals to raise their prices. We’re told that a high percentage of our population is elderly and needs more care than young people. We’re told that the issues are beyond our control. It’s just the price of practicing medicine in Vermont.
We’ve been told this for so long that we regurgitate it when asked to explain why our costs are the nation’s highest. Ain’t nothing we can do about it. Just the price of living here.
But what if you learned that the explanations were not accurate? What if the numbers showed that Vermont’s elderly don’t consume an inordinate amount of our health care spending? What if we learned that Medicare patients actually have low healthcare spending levels on a per capita basis? What if we found out that our hospitals are the ninth highest in Medicaid reimbursements, and not at the bottom, as told?
At the very least, it might prompt you to question the information we’ve been given.
According to the work of Vermont Healthcare 911 [VHC911], the mistrust is justified. The group’s investigative work, just released, shows that our high healthcare costs are due to overspending, not attributable to low reimbursement rates, poor demographics, or the elderly being disproportionately high consumers of healthcare.
VHC911’s work is critically important. Our decisions are only as good as the accuracy of the information provided. But why trust VHC911’s information?
Good question.
The first test of any advocate’s truthfulness is to understand how it profits from its work. The profit can be political or material. In VHC911’s case, it’s neither. Its co-founders are Jim Douglas, former Republican governor, and Lisa Ventriss, former president of the Vermont Business Roundtable. The board chair is Chris Pearson, a former Vermont State Senator and also a progressive. Board members include Don Tinney, president of the Vermont NEA, Bill Stritzler, owner of Smugglers’ Notch, Greg Marchildon, state director of AARP-Vermont, and others who reflect diverse backgrounds and different points of view.
By design, no one profits. The common denominator is that the organization’s members have a first-class understanding of the issue and the motivation to set the record straight. The group’s purpose is to find defensible ways to reduce the cost of healthcare in Vermont.
Vermont’s healthcare infrastructure represents 20 percent of the state’s economy. It needs to be run efficiently and with a sense of support. Hospitals are central to the communities they serve. No one wants them to shutter their doors. But we do want their services to be affordable, and currently, they are not.
We are midstream in a leadership change in Vermont’s healthcare system. Dr. Steve Leffler has taken the reins at the University of Vermont’s Medical Center and the healthcare Network. We have a new CEO, Beth-Ann Roberts, at Vermont Blue Cross Blue Shield. The Green Mountain Care Board, with the Legislature’s help, has earned our support as a regulator that can neither be bullied nor misled. Its mission is to be resolute in pushing the healthcare system toward changes that ensure the industry’s strength and longevity, and changes that make the system more affordable to Vermonters.
As we process what’s actually going on with Vermont’s healthcare system, there is a sense of hope that we may soon see an improvement in our healthcare community’s performance. That will take some patience and the confidence that the information acted upon is accurate, accessible, and widely disseminated.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here