Imagine the reaction of Vermonters if Gov. Phil Scott used his bully pulpit to say he was filled to the gills with all of us in the press who have criticized him or his politics, and that from this point forward, all stories would need to be blessed by his administration, and that any contrarians would have their press privileges pulled. Imagine if he made it clear that any negativity toward him or his administration would not be tolerated, that television affiliates could have their licenses pulled, and that any and all media outlets would be at risk of being sued for untold amounts of money if they were anything other than subservient.
In Mr. Scott’s case, we’d think he had lost his mind. The reaction in opposition would be universal and immediate. From both parties. The right to free speech is the Constitution’s First Amendment, and we can’t imagine being told we can’t say what we think as long as it does not incite the equivalent of screaming “fire” in a crowded theatre.
We would assume this reaction would be repeated in most, if not all, states. The closer the public is to its leaders, the less likely our elected leaders are to shut down the public’s right of free speech. Of all things. At a local level, such an abridgment would seem intensely personal and an easy opening for the opposition at the next election.
So why is it that President Donald Trump can run roughshod over the First Amendment without drawing immediate and widespread opposition from Congressional Republicans? In a word, fear. If you are not with him, you are against him. And this is a man who is skilled at exercising his vengeance. This past weekend, he called out, not for the first time, his Attorney General Pam Bondi to step up her investigations of his political enemies.
There are welcome signs of a push back within Mr. Trump’s own party. Texas Senator Ted Cruz used his podcast last Friday to challenge Brendan Carr, chair of the Federal Communications Commission, for his approval of the silencing of late-night comedian Jimmy Kimmel. As he said, “It might feel good right now to threaten Jimmy Kimmel, but when it is used to silence every conservative in America, we will regret it.”
Exactly.
If the president’s efforts to control our speech succeed, at any level, then why would conservatives be upset if the next Democratic president chose to follow Mr. Trump’s example and silence the speech of Republicans? Does that seem like a good strategy?
This is a tit-for-tap style of politics that threatens our Republic. But it’s also a circumstance in which both political parties share the blame. The political left knows full well that it has spent the last decade treating Mr. Trump’s devout followers as wannabe fascists. They have exercised a defined level of arrogance against conservatives, positioning themselves as the people who are nicer, smarter, and more tolerant.
It’s time for a little introspection. It’s time for both sides to tone down their penchant for inflammatory language, understanding the harm they bring down upon themselves and the rest of us. It’s an illiberalism that haunts both parties.
But, as guilty as Democrats may be with their judgmental elitism, it must be recognized that Mr. Trump is sui generis, the Latin phrase that translates to “of its own kind.” We’ve never experienced a president who has challenged our democracy in such a fundamental way, pushing it toward a level of authoritarianism we’ve always opposed as a nation. We’ve never experienced a president who campaigned to be president on the pledge that he would “restore the right to free speech” and then do the opposite, with little pushback from Republicans in Congress.
Is there reason for hope? Of course. As history shows, we’ve recovered from worse, or at least as bad.
And it was refreshing to hear from Utah Gov Spencer Cox, a Republican, who, in the aftermath of the Charlie Kirker assassination, offered a worthwhile message to us all when he said to “log off, turn off, touch grass, hug a family member, go out and do good in your community.”
Then, there was our own Mr. Scott, who said, “Our nation is broken, and we are all diminished by this loss. No matter our differences, we must strive to find common ground, reject dangerous rhetoric, and commit to dialogue over division. Violence solves nothing - it only widens the cracks in our shared foundation.”
One of those “cracks” would be the president’s push to silence his critics by tweaking the First Amendment to his own liking. Congressional Republicans may remain silent, but the masses should not.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here