Can we avoid being hit by the ''big stick'? Let's hope so.

Posted

The July floods left Vermont with a $600 million bill if we are to fully recover. It’s also a given there will be other climate-related events that could be equally punishing, and costly. Figuring out how to pay for past events and to prepare for the future, including a revamping of our infrastructure, is a daunting task. Herculean.

That’s not news. It’s understood that dealing with climate-related issues is both inexact and expensive. It’s also highly political.

All of this was on display this week in Montpelier when state agencies and outside data people testified whether Vermont is on pace to meet a 2025 emissions deadline specified in the Global Warming Solutions Act passed by the Legislature in 2020. Under the law, Vermont is required to cut its greenhouse pollution 26 percent below 2005 levels by 2025, 40 percent below 1990 levels by 2030 and 80 percent below by 2050.

So, how are we doing?

The state’s testimony, offered by Julie Moore, secretary of the Agency of Natural Resources, was upbeat. She said the state was on track to meet the law’s requirements. She was following the guidance of the Energy Futures Group, a Vermont consulting firm. The firm based its optimism on a lot of federal funding that had been piled into various emission-reducing projects.

Other data experts who testified said the modeling was incorrect and overly optimistic. Substantially so. One of those experts, David Hill, was from the firm Ms. Moore was basing her testimony. Mr. Hill acknowledged that his firm’s model was “not an appropriate measurement and verification of what’s actually happening on the ground.”

Well, that's a problem.

So where are we? Good question. But probably not as well as first suggested. Ms. Moore said, however, that the state is going in the right direction. “The investments we’ve made over the last three or four years have really fundamentally changed the trajectory we are on as a state, in terms of greenhouse gas emissions.”

But how close we are to meeting that 2025 target matters. A lot. Cutting emissions is a timely and expensive exercise and the law passed by the Legislature has a giant stick attached to make sure it’s done. According to the law, if the state fails to meet the 2025 standard anyone can sue the state, forcing it to begin a rule-making process to reduce Vermont emissions. That could include forcing the state to adopt new regulations that would ensure meeting the law’s strict, albeit arbitrary, standards.

In other words, there is the potential that an outside group - think Conservation Law Foundation - would sue the state and in the process be in a position to use its influence to say what actions would need to be employed to reduce greenhouse emissions. The cost of their “suggestions” would be borne by Vermonters, with no say in the matter.

If the law remains as is, that’s the landscape we face. By the way, the likelihood that Vermont will meet the published standards on its own is nil.

If this were a singular objective that would be one thing, it’s not. Vermont has little spare cash. Costs continue to increase. Our tax rates are high. Two critical sectors of our economy - education and health care - are absolute messes. Available housing doesn’t exist. Even the “minor” things like unfunded liabilities for our teachers and state employees continue to linger above our heads at multi-million dollar levels.

In other words, we can’t handle a complete environmental overhaul at untold expense.

No one argues the value of reducing greenhouse emissions. But there is an argument against doing it at the expense of all else. There is an argument about going forward with an omnibus approach rather than a strategic plan that prioritizes according to result and cost.

This is not a partisan issue. Understanding the need for balance and common sense is equally important to all.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here