Can Vermont put progress ahead of politics? We'll soon see.

Posted

When Gov. Phil Scott told legislators this week that voters “made it clear they want us to fix broken systems not just fund them” he captured the frustration of most Vermonters. In so doing, he also shed light on the cost of political paralysis, when the fight itself is worth more than the solution. We won’t know until the session’s end whether the Legislature and the governor can put solutions above politics, but the cause has been made by the voters.

What we do know is that the governor has made the offer. What we do know is that he has stripped the argument down to the barest essentials on at least three key issues: the cost of education, the need for housing, and the cry for a beefed-up public safety initiative. [The only thing missing from the governor’s budget speech was the need to address the state’s health care crisis.]

If these issues can be addressed in a way that fixes things, the session will be an unqualified success. If not, as the governor said, we will have a budget that continues to fund broken systems, which is an expensive and unproductive way to run a state.

How the debates unfold and are reported to the public will play a major role in determining the outcome. Politics is still the art of using messaging for one’s self-interest. This will be particularly evident in the debate over how to move forward with a new educational system. 

When the particulars of the governor’s ed proposal are made public there will be opposition to every suggestion. It’s easier to keep things as they are than to change. The messaging from both the governor and legislators needs to make it clear that standing still makes what we have so expensive and so below par academically. That’s also a message that should be telegraphed by the Vermont NEA. Our teachers have a huge stake in what happens. They, too, will suffer if nothing changes and should resist their natural tendency to oppose whatever is proposed.

This determination applies to our housing needs as well. The governor said the state needs to build 7,000 units “just to keep our head above water.” We are nowhere close to that. Last year’s legislation to expand Act 250 to encourage more housing was more an environmental bill than a housing bill and falls utterly in matching a solution to a need.

But the housing debate is a difficult one to follow, and orchestrate. Not only do we need to rid ourselves of the regulations that make building homes at scale almost impossible, we need to do a better job selling the message. Perhaps that could be the charge of the new housing advocacy group Let’s Build Homes. Keep the message in front of Vermonters and their elected officials. Establish a relationship with the Vermont League of Cities and Towns to keep track of the number of housing permits granted. If we need 7,000 new homes built each year then let us know how close [or far] we are from the goal. Don’t assume Vermonters know the nuances involved in our housing challenge. Legislators [and the governor] should treat the issue like political campaigns. After all, it’s about self-interest. Vermont’s. 

Intertwined with the need for new housing is the state’s need to step up when it comes to our laws governing public safety. It’s hard to sell homes in the middle of our cities and towns if people look at them as unsafe places to live. A 40 percent increase in reports of shoplifting from 2022 to 2023, or a 40 percent increase in aggravated assaults between 2018 and 2023 are not welcoming signs. When you have a judicial system that is short on accountability and has almost no ability to effectively deal with repeat offenders then it’s absurd to expect any other response from the public than what we have, which is one of outrage and frustration. The longer it goes untended, the faster it will intensify as a political issue. 

Dealing with these issues, and others, will, as the governor says, “leave this place better than we found it.” Let’s push both the governor and the Legislature to hold true to the promise of fixing things that are broken.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here