Every 10 years the Vermont Legislature must redistrict the House and Senate to reflect the state’s change in population. That will begin in January and will reflect the population shift from southern and eastern Vermont to northwestern Vermont, including Chittenden, Franklin, Lamoille and Grand Isle counties.
The Legislative Apportionment Board has toiled for a good portion of the year to figure out how both the Senate and House could best reflect the requirement that each district have a population within 10 percent of the state average. They have drawn together a proposal for the House and are in the process of doing the same for the Senate.
No matter the proposals, the process is one fraught with the fear of change. It’s impossible to redesign a political map and not have it affect legislators or the towns being represented. Bennington County, for example, is looking at a decline in representation whereas Franklin and Chittenden counties are looking at adding representation. One loses, the other gains. The reapportionment board also voted 4-3 to move from the existing apportionment plan to one in which all districts are represented by a single representative. That’s not a likely outcome, given the closeness of the vote and the reluctance of legislators to embrace wholesale change. But the end result - expected by April at the latest - will be different than what we have.
In Franklin County, the proposed apportionment plan for the House doesn’t seem to pit incumbents against one another as it would in other districts. St. Albans City, for example, is presently a two-member district comprised of Rep. Michael McCarthy and Rep. Casey Toof. Even with the push to single-member districts, the apportionment board simply split the city in two districts. Mr. McCarthy and Mr. Toof would represent single districts; voters would have to become familiar with how the city was split and to which member they could turn. It's awkward, but doable, should that be the final choice.
It’s how Franklin County would be affected in the Senate that should hold our attention. Two proposals are currently in circulation. One, proposed by Jeanne Albert, puts Franklin County in two districts. One is Franklin County as it is now, with two changes: We would lose the people of Fairfax and Georgia, and pick up the people of Eden and Belvidere. The other district is a Chittenden, Franklin, Grand Isle District made up of Grand Isle, Colchester, Fairfax, Georgia and Milton. Both districts would be represented by two senators.
The second proposal is by Jeremy Hansen, which breaks us up in three ways: First is the Chittenden, Grand Isle and Franklin County district and would include South Hero, Grand Isle, Alburg, Highgate, Swanton, Shelton, Franklin and Berkshire. Then, there is Franklin County North, which includes St. Albans, Fairfield, Bakersfield and Montgomery. Then, there is Franklin County South, which includes Georgia, Fairfax, Fletcher, Johnson and Underhill.
There may be other iterations submitted before the Legislature convenes in January and the process itself is subject to change when the committees begin to tinker with the proposals. Twinned with this is the requirement that the senatorial representation in Chittenden Country be changed from its current form in which the county elects six at large members. What we don’t know is how it will be changed - the basic thought is that the City of Burlington will lose representation to other Chittenden County towns like Milton, Colchester, Essex and Williston.
That population change also matches the recent growth patterns in Franklin County. Our growth has been strongest in Fairfax, Georgia and greater St. Albans. It would be preferable for the county if we could add a third senator to our existing duo of Sen. Randy Brock and Sen. Corey Parent, something that might be doable by adding Milton to our numbers, and keeping Georgia and Fairfax.
We’re leery of losing Georgia and Fairfax, as proposed in one plan, and also having the county chopped up in another. Rather than have the Chittenden County “influence” drift up, we’d rather have the Franklin County “influence” drift down.
There isn’t any easy answer to any of this. It’s like trying to put together a giant puzzle. When you take from one, you must add to another. The numbers have to balance out and we should also be hesitant to create districts where there are obvious incompatibilities. We’re not sure, for example, what sort of affinity the people in Belvidere and Eden have for our Franklin County representation in the Senate. On the other hand, the people in Milton have a pretty strong connection to Franklin County.
No matter the process, the outcome is of considerable importance to us. There are only 30 members of the Senate. If Franklin County - in the main - could add another senator to its mix it would play to our advantage until the next reapportionment ten years hence.
It’s worth the effort to see what can be done.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here