Bill would correct a flawed DCF process; needs to be passed

Posted

 In March of 2023, we wrote about the work of the Vermont Parent Representation Center [VPRC] which had thoroughly documented how children in Vermont were being taken from their parents for unsubstantiated reasons and how parents were placed on a registry without proper protocols. The call was for legislation to correct the transgressions which meant a dramatic change in how Vermont’s Department for Children and Families did its job.

The attention to the issue generated a significant response, particularly from those parents falsely charged with abuse and neglect, parents who felt their pleas of innocence were lost to a bureaucracy that gave them no recourse.

This attention came about through VPRC’s heroic efforts to prove the system’s inherent flaws. The group began “The Substantiation Project” which accepted and examined 30 appeals from individuals judged by DCF as guilty of child abuse or neglect. The project ended up being a three-year process and one that would have cost between $10,000 to $50,000 per appeal. 

As we noted last year, the result was that every appeal was overturned or withdrawn. All 30. DCF’s procedures were obviously deeply flawed and parents and their children were hurt. To put it mildly.

It’s hard to hide from those sorts of numbers. The obvious question is how many others were falsely charged and how many children were wrongly taken from their parents? There are 25,000 Vermonters whose names are on the child protection registry, who are basically unemployable. That is a substantial number. How many are on the registry who should not be?

It is notoriously difficult to force a bureaucracy to change its ways, particularly one vested with the responsibility of protecting our children. They are the professionals, we defer to them. They are reflexively defensive.

But the attention devoted to the issue caught not only the interest of legislators but the Commissioner of DCF Chris Winters, who had been appointed to the position in March 2023, just as VPRC’s information became public. 

Mr. Winters pressed his own department to run a parallel investigation of its practices. The investigation verified VPRC’s conclusion. The department’s practices were flawed. But rather than ignore the obvious Mr. Winters - in late 2023 - put together a stakeholders group, including DCF, the purpose being to reform the system, to correct its practices, and to increase the level of transparency. 

The result of the stakeholders’ work is a robust list of reforms - agreed to by all parties - that has become the core of H.661. The legislation would change “investigation and substantiation standards” and rework the rules and procedures for someone to be placed on the Child Protection Registry. It would also address how someone’s name could be removed.

The House Human Services Committee held extensive hearings on the bill and last month it was reported out of committee on an 11-0 vote. It passed the full house on a unanimous voice vote. The bill is now before the Senate Committee on Health and Welfare, which yesterday began its hearings.

If the legislation passes, it will be the first time in 40 years DCF has undergone any level of reform. Clearly, it’s time. The system is broken. Parents are being wrongly accused. Children are being unnecessarily traumatized. All parties, including DCF, agree that what is now in place does not work and they are open to changing it so that it does.

The VPRC, a small band of volunteers, needs to be commended for the work it did to bring the necessary attention to the issue. Mr. Winters is to be commended for the fortitude necessary to bring his agency into compliance and to change its processes. It has passed the House and needs to be approved by the Senate before this session is adjourned. That will require the continued input and support of Mr. Winters and his department. 

This is a win-win opportunity for all involved. It changes a flawed system. It makes DCF a better, more transparent operation. It helps restore trust. And it helps prevent any further injustice to families and their children.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here