Baruth should not make same mistake twice

Posted

Ethics complaints were filed last week against Sens. Seth Bongartz, D-Bennington, and Scott Beck, R-Caledonia for misusing their influence as members of the “committee of conference” appointed to sort out differences between the House and Senate on S.454, the session’s landmark education reform law.

Mr. Bongartz has a long history with Burr and Burton, a private school in Manchester and Mr. Beck is a teacher at St. Johnsbury Academy. The complaint alleges that throughout the House-Senate negotiations both senators “crossed the line” in their defense of Vermont’s private schools.

They probably did. Mr. Bongartz has a deep allegiance to Burr and Burton, as does Mr. Beck with St. Johnsbury Academy. It would be unreasonable to think they would be obligated to vote in favor of legislation that harms what they support and what their constituents expect.

The complaints were filed by Friends of Vermont Public Education board member Geo Honigford. As an organization, it is generally opposed to Vermont’s private schools receiving taxpayer dollars if they don’t follow the same rules imposed on public schools. In other words, the complaint wasn’t a shock given the complainant’s views.

It was also no surprise that Mr. Bongartz and Mr. Beck responded in kind. They were defensive of their roles and dismissive of the ethics complaint filed. Mr. Bongartz called it “garbage” and said, “They don’t like the fact that I’m an articulate voice for something that they don’t like.”

The problem is not that Mr. Beck and Mr. Bongartz pushed conference negotiations in a way that benefited Vermont’s private schools. That could only be expected. The problem is that Senate President Pro Tempore Phillip Baruth appointed them as two of the Senate’s three negotiators in the first place. Private schools in Vermont constitute roughly 10 percent of Vermont’s student population. To say private schools were over-represented on the conference committee is an understatement. Mr. Baruth had 29 people to pick from and 27 of them have no equivalent ties to Vermont’s independent schools. 

Admittedly, both senators have legislative positions that would, on the surface, argue for being appointed to the conference committee. Mr. Bongartz is chair of the Senate Committee on Education and Mr. Beck is on Senate Finance. But Mr. Bongartz’s effort, as chair, to come up with his own educational reform bill was an utter disaster. The Senate went to conference with essentially the same bill passed by the House. Regardless, both senators saw being appointed to the conference committee as their last chance to affect the bill’s outcome and protect the state’s private school community. They pushed, and they got what they wanted.

Neither senator has anything to worry about regarding the ethics complaint. They did nothing wrong and did what anyone would expect them to do. 

But a mistake made once needn’t be repeated.

Next week we will learn whether that’s a lesson Mr. Baruth has learned.  The new law requires Vermont to establish new school districts, and supervisory union lines by December. The task force is to draw up three proposals for the Legislature to consider. The governor has named David Wolk as his choice to sit on the task force. House Speaker Jill Krowinski will name her five next week and Mr. Baruth is expected to name his five soon as well. Of the 10, six must be legislators [not from the same party]. Three are to come from the House and three from the Senate.

Mr. Bongartz and Mr. Beck have already expressed an interest. 

Why would Mr. Baruth appoint either, or both, knowing in advance the friction it would create and the lack of public trust that would cloud the work of the 11-person task force as a result?

He shouldn’t. He should use his persuasive skills to find others better suited to push the state’s landmark educational reform bill forward.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here