Back to the drawing board for Georgia’s library renovation work; Selectboard rejects $26,400 scope of work

Posted

GEORGIA – It’s back to the drawing board for Georgia's public library renovations after the selectboard found the price to get a scope of work too expensive. 

In a unanimous decision May 25, all five of Georgia’s selectboard members pressed pause on having Civil Engineering Associates and Colin Lindberg Architects design American Disabilities Act improvements for the library’s entrance. The firms said the design only would cost $26,400, which is above the town’s budget. 

Since the municipality formed a revitalization committee in April of last year to get the building up to ADA standards, the group has met a half-dozen times and been billed for almost $31,000 in fees, according to Kellie Bosenberg, selectboard chair and revitalization committee member. 

The library’s renovation project has a total of $50,000 in reserve funds allocated for the design implementation phase. No physical work has been completed. 

Since talk of renovating the library reignited in 2025, selectboard and library staff have not seen eye-to-eye on the project. 

From the library’s point of view, the revitalization is a chance to update the building with more modern amenities. The committee initially asked engineers for a scope of work that would create a new entryway in the back of the building so the community room could be accessed after the library is closed. That plan, if completed, would have cost $800,000 to $1.2 million and included upgrades to the parking lot and interior lighting. 

After the engineers presented that plan, library trustee and revitalization committee member Terry Cleveland said trustees were faced with a change of plans.  

“By about the seventh meeting, members of our committee who were on the selectboard said, ‘You need to go back and just do the plain old ADA compliant, getting into the building in the current entryway,’” Cleveland said. “They did have to go back to redesign just that piece of it, and then they had to go back to HVAC and electrical people to say ‘Ok, now what is the scope going to look like if we just do that piece?’” 

The selectboard had hoped to acquire a Housing and Urban Development grant, only to find out the project wouldn’t qualify later in the process. The decision was then made to get a quote for stripped down renovations instead. 

For that plan, Civil Engineering Associates and Colin Lindberg Architects quote $26,400, which left Brian Dunsmore, selectboard vice chair and revitalization committee member, frustrated, he said. 

“They came back and said ‘Oh well if you want to pay us another twenty-something thousand dollars we’ll tell you what the ADA version is,’ and that kind of made me mad,” he said. 

Both the selectboard and the library are on the same page about work needing to be done in the parking lot to make the building more accessible to the general public. 

A difference of opinion 

Disagreements over the scope of the work between library trustees and selectboard members is nothing new. Since at least 2018, when the selectboard began to examine the state of its buildings, the library has had a different perspective from the board. 

“There’s an obvious difference between what the selectboard had for their list and what the library committee had,” said Jim Lintereur of VIS Construction Consultants at the time. “Of course, budget’s going to play a major role in all this.” 

At that time, the proposed costs for a more comprehensive library project were roughly $300,000 – a number then-selectboard members gawked at – $50,000 would later be added on to the estimate.  

“I think we’ve gone way overboard from what we envisioned,” then-selectboard member Ric Nye said. “I thought we were going to have a sidewalk and a door.” 

By the time the next year rolled around, the library project was shelved in favor of maintenance on the town’s highway department garage and eventually new garage construction. 

Although the current selectboard did not approve the current engineer’s scope of work, members of the board did agree to reach out to other contractors and engineers the town has worked with in an attempt to get different estimates before deciding next steps.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here