Voters, generally speaking, don’t know, much less care about political controversies until it affects them personally. Then, they don’t forget or forgive. That happened last November when the Democrats lost their supermajorities in the Legislature. Voters blamed the Democrats for the 14 percent hike in their property taxes and voted down their school budgets.,
To recover, Democrats have lowered their profiles and have paired their efforts with the governor’s to reform the educational system and to do so in a way that shows them sympathetic to the voters’ pocketbook.
Democrats don't want to be burned twice which requires them to act with some humility and to search for that little bit of patience that acknowledges the governor is the one with the public's trust, not them.
But power is difficult to give up and while the Democrats may have learned their lesson with education and how we fund our schools [maybe], they are giving the voters another pocketbook issue, which is the every day price we pay for energy. It’s a two-pronged issue cloaked in the obtuse, regulatory language of the Global Warming Solutions Act [GWSA] and the Clean Heat Standard.
Most Vermonters will never get past the laws’ names. They are complicated and beyond understanding for all but the very few. In sum, the laws are intended to reduce Vermont’s level of greenhouse gas emissions. The most recent, the Clean Heat Standard, is focused on establishing a carbon credit on home heating fuels aimed at the state’s thermal sector. The Global Warming Solutions Act, was broader, setting near and long-term goals for overall gas emissions. Both have been found - even by the assigned state regulators - to be complicated, expensive, and beyond the state’s scope to run.
This was the feedback the Legislature requested, yet the Democratic leadership continues its push forward undeterred, no matter the cost to Vermonters.
This happens because the special interest with the political pull in Vermont is the environmental movement. While most Legislators [and Vermonters] favor either repealing the laws or, at the very least, rewriting them, a tight little band of lobbyists and legislators continue to push forward. The Conservation Law Foundation continues its march for both laws, but, specifically the GWSA. Recognizing how unpopular the Clean Heat Standard is with voters, several legislators are trying to leverage its repeal into fundamentally shifting the money Vermonters are currently charged for electric efficiency to reducing greenhouse gas emissions – a move guaranteed to raise the cost Vermonters pay for electricity.
As regards the GWSA legislation, give credit to Agency of Natural Resources Secretary Julie Moore for putting truth to power recently in an op-ed saying what everyone knows: “The 2030 emissions reduction requirements are unattainable...No one serious about climate action in the State House, or in major environmental interest groups, believes there's the political will to enact either policy this year,”
Yet, there has been no effort to change course; to find another way to accomplish the same purpose - reduced emissions. Worse, is that legislators are being pushed to allow the law to remain intact, understanding that the law allows the state to be sued for not being able to meet those standards. The Conservation Law Foundation [CLF] has done as much, which not only wastes time but costs the taxpayer. It’s one of the most foolish things the Legislature has done in recent memory.
As Ms. Moore wrote: “It laid bare that CLF would rather spend their time and our time in court battles instead of investing in the tangible work needed to reduce carbon emissions.”
It’s important to recognize that the state has not been delinquent in its efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The current budget includes $520 million for such projects. That’s not chump change.
Not only are the ineffectual laws costing Vermont taxpayers a lot of money, they are doing so in a way that makes it difficult for the state to redirect its efforts in a productive manner. After all, shouldn’t the objective be to develop policies that do work rather than to waste time and money in court?
The Senate’s push to place the Clean Heat Standard's requirements on the back of Efficiency Vermont’s billing system is also a ruse. It’s not budget-neutral. The intent is to shift funding from unregulated fossil fuel sources to the regulated infrastructure of the state’s electricity grid.
That’s diametrically opposed to what should be happening. Why would we want to push the cost of electricity skyward, a process that not only duplicates what Vermont’s utilities do in the first place [focus on the efficient delivery of our power] but something that would raise the price of our power to homeowners and industry?
This proposal, which passed out of committee last week, has not only attracted the opposition of all the state’s utilities and business groups but the Vermont Public Utility Commission and Department of Public Service as well. The reason is simple: Why would Vermont raise the price of electricity - a low-emission source of energy, something we’d rather Vermonters use more of, rather than fossil fuel sources that are unregulated, and contribute more to the greenhouse gas challenge?
It is not defensible for Vermont’s electric ratepayers to be billed for fossil fuel efficiency projects. Vermonters are already at the tips of their spears in terms of affordability. Raising the cost of electricity in a self-defeating purpose is nonsense.
The picture being sent to Vermonters is a split screen: one half has us spending our time in court being sued for something that all sides agree can’t be controlled, i.e., meeting emission reduction standards for 2030; the other half is a half-baked proposal to put Efficiency Vermont in charge of greenhouse gas emission projects and to fund them through ever- increasing rate charges to Vermonters.
The full picture is one of, yet again, higher costs and unmet needs. The Democratic leadership needs to know that Vermonters will soon figure this out.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here