Another check you deserve

Posted

It’s understood the impact of the pandemic has not affected us all in equal measure. Restaurants, bars and hospitals, for example, have been devastated. Car insurance, landscapers, hardware stores and the online behemoths have done well. But what about health insurance companies; the ones that charge us each month to cover our health care needs?

The companies — Blue Cross Blue Shield and MVP in Vermont — depend entirely on the patients in our health care system. The greater the patient demand, the more the insurance companies must pay out in claims. But, for the months of March, April, May and part of June, the demand for health care services evaporated. Hospitals were shut down for all but emergency care. Doctors practiced telemedicine, but little in-the-office care. The number of health care claims plummeted.

But we kept paying our monthly premiums and unlike the automobile insurance business, the health care insurers aren’t volunteering to send us any surprise checks to reflect their unexpected savings.

The insurance companies will submit their proposed budgets to the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] in late July or early August. It will be interesting to see how the companies defend asking for an increase in rates, because you know they will. Even if it’s just a smidgen.

The obvious defense for the companies would be to say they need a rate increase to meet the pent up demand caused by Covid-19. People who could not get their surgeries or care in March, April and May would get their care in the following months. They would need to prepare for the expected surge.

But that’s not really possible. Hospitals were already backlogged and there are only so many hours in the day. The crisis has also prompted hospitals to cut staff, and we’ve long had a shortage of physicians — two factors that may make it difficult for hospitals to even get back to operating levels they had before the pandemic. There will be patients that were scheduled for treatment but have recovered on their own. And there’s the fact that during the shut down people were less exposed to the things that make them sick, or less exposed to activities that cause injury. There are insurance-covered programs that hospitals and doctors’ offices provide that patients will elect to forgo, just because they are fearful of being around others. No matter how it’s analyzed, it’s almost impossible to see how BCBS or MVP don’t benefit financially. And perhaps by quite a bit.

So when BCBS and MVP collect the premiums each and every month, yet have few claims to process for more than 25 percent of the year, it’s hard to see how they didn’t benefit enormously, and even harder to understand why the GMCB would do anything other than ask them to reduce their rates. The board has no issue in asking hospitals to reduce their rates, it needs to do the same with BCBS and MVP.

Ask any school board member how important it would be for them to see a reduction in their health care premiums. Ask any city manager. Ask any businesses. Ask any Vermonter.

by Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here