There is an old saying that points out the obvious: when something doesn’t make sense, or deviates from the norm, and you want to know why, follow the money.
That was the intent of the Green Mountain Care Board when it discovered that rural Medicare recipients were paying more for their healthcare at our small “critical care hospitals” than Medicare recipients at “acute care” hospitals, the state’s largest.
Outwardly, it makes no sense. The medical procedures examined by the board were the same. The costs were also the same; the large hospitals charged no more than our small, rural hospitals for the same procedure. The board discovered that the difference between our large hospitals and our small hospitals was Medicare’s cost-sharing policies.
For large hospitals - like the UVM Medical Center - Medicare patients pay 20 percent of the Medicare payment amount listed on the bill. For the state’s small rural hospitals, Medicare beneficiaries pay 20 percent of what the hospitals are able to charge for their outpatient care. What that means is that Medicare patients would pay less in a large acute care hospital because Medicare pays the hospital for the price of the service charged and nothing more. In a small hospital, which does not have the acute care hospital distinction, the hospital is able to charge not only the cost of the service, but whatever else it wants to include in the Medicare patient’s bill.
As GMCB chair Owen Foster says, that’s a problem. “It is really, really troubling that some of our seniors may be paying a lot more if they’re in a rural community as opposed to Chittenden County … Financing of health care in Vermont must be sufficient, fair, predictable, transparent, sustainable, and shared equitably.”
That’s a troubling circumstance for most of Vermont. The people in our poorest counties - Essex, Orleans, and Caledonia - are also the oldest. The median household income in Chittenden County, for example, is $91,000 to $94,000. The median household income in rural Vermont is $54,000-$59,000. The median age in Chittenden County is a bit over 38. The median age in our most rural areas is almost 52. Since older Vermonters have higher demands for health care than younger Vermonters, this disparity in Medicare billing practices places a disproportionate burden on the Vermonters most vulnerable.
According to Mr. Foster, it’s the board’s intent to have the state’s critical access hospitals correct this wrong.
But how big a problem is this? Isn’t this something that can be easily rectified?
Well, let’s follow the money.
In a Vermont Digger story on the issue, Olivia Sweetnam, the CEO of Grace Cottage Family Health and Hospital in Townshend responded to the issue, saying that reducing the cost of the charges would “surely bankrupt” the hospital. According to Devon Green, spokesperson for the Vermont Association of Hospitals and Health Systems, most of the state’s critical care hospitals share that same fear.
Let’s get that straight. The hospital in Townshend survives because it charges its most vulnerable patients over and above what UVM Medical Center charges? And the hospital is able to keep its doors open because they have an older demographic that uses them more than UVM’s younger, healthier demographic?
And the state’s seven other critical access hospitals feel similarly?
Apparently. So, when Mr. Foster and the other four board members made it clear they would not tolerate the pricing policies of our “critical care” hospitals because they were charging our older, rural patients unfairly, what’s the answer if those same hospitals contend they have no other way to keep their doors open?
It would seem apparent that since the policies that govern Medicare are federal and not controlled by the state, the feds would need to correct the problem. But how likely is that since any change to the rules would apply to all other states, and that Vermont - one of the nation’s smallest and oldest states - is an outlier?
Mr. Foster has asked for more information this week. He wants the problem addressed in next fiscal year’s budget cycle. “We already know that rural Vermonters are being charged prices that are neither defensible nor sustainable. It is unacceptable for this to persist into another fiscal year.”
In an election year, one would think this would capture the attention of those with their names on the ballot. Asking the elderly [who we have in abundance] to shoulder an unfair burden in today’s affordability environment should be something politicians would want to address.
We’ll see. It doesn’t seem like an issue the Green Mountain Care Board is willing to ignore. It’s following the money.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here