Aly Richards will raise level of gubernatorial election

Posted

If Gov. Phil Scott runs for reelection and wins, then sometime in mid-2028, he would officially eclipse former Gov. Howard Dean’s record of 11 years, four months, and 27 days. He is currently the longest-serving governor in Vermont’s history, with the exception of Thomas Chittenden, Vermont’s first governor, who served 19 years in office, most of which was before Vermont became a state.

A key difference between the two governors’ races is that the longer Mr. Scott has served, the more popular he has become, whereas in Mr. Dean’s case, the longer he served, the narrower his victories.

Mr. Scott’s first race against Democrat Sue Mintor in 2016 ended with him prevailing by 8.7 percent. In 2018, he beat Christine Hallquist by 14.9 percent. In 2020, he clobbered David Zuckerman by 41.1 percent, Brenda Siegel in 2022 by 47 percent, and Esther Charlestin in 2024 by 51.6 percent.

Mr. Dean’s first race in 1992 was against John McClaughry, whom he beat by 51.7 percent. In 1994, he beat David Kelley by 49.7 percent, John Gropper in 1996 by 48 percent, Ruth Dwyer in 1998 by 14.6 percent, and Ruth Dwyer and Anthony Pollina by 12.4 percent in 2000.

In Vermont politics, particularly for gubernatorial races, it’s typically the case that the longer a person serves, the harder it is for them to maintain the public’s goodwill. No matter the competency level, voters usually show their readiness to move on to someone new, with different ideas.

In the examples of both Mr. Scott and Mr. Dean, they shared the ability to govern from the political middle. As governor, Mr. Dean was a fiscal moderate, particularly in his first two terms. The same, obviously, applies to Mr. Scott, who has made affordability the center of his political being for the last decade. Mr. Scott has also been helped by the Democratic majorities in the Legislature, allowing him to campaign as the necessary counterbalance to the party’s left wing, something he still does.

It was generally expected that the person most likely to challenge Mr. Scott would be Mike Pieciak, the state’s treasurer, who has spent most of the last year keeping a high profile and maximizing every issue to its political utmost. When he said he would not be a candidate, it looked as if the Democrats would repeat the past, conceding to the governor with another selection from their weak bench.

On Monday, Aly Richards, the former CEO of Let’s Grow Kids, blew a little wind into her party’s sails with her announcement that it's time for a new approach.” She’s a long shot. The odds of Mr. Scott winning in November are overwhelmingly. But Ms. Richards is far and away the most formidable candidate Mr. Scott has faced. She has a deep political pedigree, including a stint as Gov. Peter Shumlin’s chief of staff. She’s very smart. She is good on the stump. And she’s amassed an impressive list of supporters from one end of the state to the other.

Most importantly, she can back up her “time for a new approach” campaign with her “Let’s Grow Kids” success that changed the face of child care in Vermont. She devoted a full ten years to the task of educating Vermonters as to the need and then figuring out a way to harness the energy of over 40,000 Vermonters to get the Legislature to pass the landmark child care law. Her success stands out as a sterling example of leadership, determination, and resilience. She took on one of the state’s thorniest issues and prevailed.

What she asks is straightforward: Don’t we want this same level of energy and thought applied to health care [she is vice chair of the Board of Trustees of UVM Medical Center], housing, education, and the general issue of affordability?

As to what happens in November, the visibility is zero. There is a big difference between having command of issues and being able to connect with the voters. Running a statewide campaign is a substantial challenge that requires a different sort of talent. Mr. Scott has built up a reservoir of goodwill and confidence. He has a talented and skilled staff. He’s the nation’s most popular governor and a Republican in a deeply blue state. No mean achievement.

But Ms. Richards’ talent and drive are a welcome improvement to the challengers the Democrats have fielded in the last five elections. Having two talented candidates is also what brings the best ideas to the surface and what motivates Vermonters to get involved.

Should Mr. Scott prevail to become Vermont’s longest-serving governor, it will be a better thing for him to do so, having been challenged by someone like Ms. Richards, who, no matter the outcome, elevates what Vermonters can expect from their candidates in the November election.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here