Affordable housing: What we don't know

Posted

Housing in Vermont that people can afford, twined with housing that is even available have bedeviled the state since Guttenberg hit on the idea of movable type. On Tuesday, a meeting was convened in St. Albans by the Vermont Senate Committee on Economic Development, Housing and General Affairs to gather input from locals as to why the issue exists, its significance and possible ideas as to how it could be addressed.

The hearing came about because legislators are pushing to consider support of the state’s housing bond program.

The conclusions, if they can be called that, were basically a repeat of all that has been said time and time again. Wages are not sufficient to afford what the market provides. Regulations are too costly and onerous. Demand for housing isn’t sufficient to generate the supply, and on and on.

That’s not a criticism; it’s just the process. Public meeting like this are held, the same information is curated, and we are left where we began.

What would be helpful is if the time and resources were spent to be able to gather the data that would really tell us what the issues are and what they represent in dollars and cents.

One of the developers present — Chris Snyder — told the committee that he had a housing project in Shelburne that required five years to get through the regulatory hurdles. It’s a story that’s been told and retold. Decade after decade.

But no one has ever put a number to the regulatory challenge. When a developer tries to build a house, or housing complex, how much do regulations add to the purchase price? If Mr. Snyder’s project had been approved in 12 months versus 60 what would the difference have meant to the homeowner? Surely in this age of big data that information can be teased out.

There is also non-profit factor. There are a number of affordable housing non-profits in Vermont, which also have tie-ins to federal funding. They are considered one of the state’s “sacred cows” when it comes to legislative protectiveness. Their appropriations have a protective political shield about them.

No one suggests it’s inappropriate for the non-profits to be involved with affordable housing; to the contrary, they are important players.

But they are also facilitators, or middlemen. They get a cut of the action, which is one of the ways they stay afloat. It’s not a charity.

That’s fine, but what does that represent in terms of affecting the price of the “affordable” housing?

It may not be much, or it could be sizable. We don’t know. And we need to, or we can’t discuss the issue with any degree of certainty.

There are issues of zoning and local regulations regarding density, etc. How old are the regulations? Are they appropriate to today’s challenges? What are they and what are their effects?

We have the nation’s second-oldest housing stock, are there things in place that limit our ability to upgrade, to take things down so the land can be used more productively?

The point is this: It’s wrong to assume we have the information we need to make good decisions. We don’t. It’s wrong to assume the general public has a good understanding of the challenge and can even remotely put a dollar and cent figure to the issue. And it’s wrong to assume legislators have a solid understanding of what it is that makes housing in Vermont so expensive, and limited in availability.

The question to legislators is this: How can the taxpayers’ dollars be spent wisely to deal with affordable housing if we don’t have a firm hand on the numbers?

They can’t.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here