A town meeting train wreck no one knows how to derail

Posted

Vermont’s legislative leadership last week sent a letter to the state’s school boards and superintendents about the “unintended consequences” of Act 127, the law intended to create a more equitable funding structure between schools. In short, the law’s purpose was to change the weighting formula to benefit schools with economically disadvantaged students. This shift in funding would be picked up by Vermont’s wealthier schools. The letter suggests that some wealthy school districts are taking advantage of provisions in the law in a way that threatens to break the bank.

When our legislators passed the bill, it was acknowledged that the wealthier school districts needed a little protection, otherwise, they would face forced budget cuts year one. A provision was added to allow school tax rates to be capped at 5 percent for five years. That would give the schools time to adjust. These schools were also limited to rate increases of 10 percent; above that would require the school to submit their budgets to the state.

When the legislation was made law, many of our wealthier school districts saw the law for what it was, a five-year window of basically free money. It was also mandatory that a school hit the 5 percent cap the first year, otherwise they would be ineligible the remaining four years.

The school board representing Mount Mansfield Union School District sent a memo to its Stowe-centric community that summarized the law and its opportunity succinctly:

“The 5% tax rate cap is a lifeline for our District and allows us to make substantial improvements to our aging buildings, grounds and infrastructure without changing the tax rate… therefore we have added $5.67 million in building/facility upgrades and improvements to the 2024-25 budget.

“It is important to note that with or without these investments, MMUUSD tax rate will be the same. In order for MMUUSD to get below the 5% tax rate cap, we would need to cut $5.83 million from the proposed budget…

“The board acknowledges that the proposed increase of 18.7 percent in the 2024-25 budget is considerably higher than previous budgets. However we recognize that the District has an opportunity to include non-recurring investments for our facilities that do not affect the tax rate. “To provide some context, under the terms of Act 127, the MMUUSD tax rate will be the same if we have a 1.7% decrease or a 18.7 increase in the year-over-year total expenditures.”

There it is. The MMUSD school board saw the law as a “lifeline” to make up for deferred maintenance, which is about as far from Act 127’s intent to improve equity as one can imagine. And the proposed $5.67 million would not force MMUSD to raise taxes a dime.

The thinking of MMUUSD’s school board is no different than any other school board in Vermont facing the same issues with the same opportunities. What’s baffling is that legislators did not anticpate this when the bill was being discussed. If a school board can spend millions more without burdening their own district’s taxpayers, and have five years to do so, why wouldn’t they? If the state has no school construction program [it was suspended in 2007] why wouldn’t schools leap at the chance to fix up their buildings, spreading the cost to others in the state?

The rub, of course, is two-fold: First, although MMUUSD’s taxpayers will not be strapped with the extra costs directly, the rest of Vermont will be. There is no free money. It must come from somewhere, rich and poor alike. Second, the timing of this poorly-crafted law could not be worse. All Vermont’s school boards have submitted their budgets. They cannot be redone and resubmitted. And if the rest of Vermont’s school districts have proposed budgets near what MMUSD has submitted, then Vermont is looking at double-digit rate increases. Estimates range between 12 and 18 percent.

Vermont already has a property tax rate that is among the highest in the nation. A double-digit increase in school budgets will force property taxes skyward. Taxpayers, in all likelihood, will revolt, which, in turn, weakens the bond between communities and their schools.

It’s an impending train wreck that no one knows how to derail. Not only is the five percent threshold being used to create less equity between school districts, not more, it’s inflating costs that were not anticipated and creating more turbulence within Vermont’s educational system.

As we’ve said before, it’s a mess.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here