Here is the puzzle: You have a $2.56 billion company with a staff of roughly 90,000. You need a CEO to run the place. There is no heir-apparent. The product you produce is unique to the market and pivotal to the state’s well-being. What would you spend to find the person to run the company, and for how long would you allow the search to take?
The example is not made-up. It is happening in Vermont. In fact, the application process for that CEO ended Thursday. It was roughly a two-month search. Total cost for the search was $495. The job search was largely conducted online, using the usual suspects, LinkedIn, Facebook, etc. No head-hunters. No national search.
The job?
Education Secretary for Vermont’s Agency of Education.
The agency itself has a staff of 170 people [with 14 current staff openings]. But its reach, and its responsibilities, extend to every school and every classroom in Vermont. The state’s 80,000 students depend on it, as do the 7,000 or so teachers/school staff. The rest of Vermont also depends on it - our economy and the strength of our communities are only as good as what comes out of our schools.
Why, then, is the state’s effort to recruit a new education secretary so minimal? Why would the average school district spend $20,000 to get a new superintendent, yet the state spends less than $500 to find that leader who, in turn, guides the superintendents, etc.?
Is that where education ranks with the Scott administration, the folks to whom the education secretary reports?
If so, then we need to change how the agency of eduction works.
It used to be that we had a commissioner of education who answered to a State Board of Education. The commissioner was independent and not beholden to the governor’s office. That changed in the opening years of the Peter Shumlin administration. Gov. Shumlin wanted more control of what happened in education and convinced the Legislature to change the law to give him that control. The change worked because Mr. Shumlin’s first hire was Rebecca Holcombe, who was spectacular in the job.
That level leadership has not been present since. A recent survey of Vermont school administrators has indicated as much, and the call for renewed purpose from the agency has been made clear from our educators.
What is not clear is why we need a State Board of Education if the Education Secretary’s position is to remain under the governor’s direction. Instead of the board serving as a buffer between the educational establishment and the governor, the responsibilities should be handled by the governor’s office, just as other agencies are. No political buffer necessary.
If not, then the Legislature should consider returning to the commissioner system, keeping the state board of education, but no longer keeping the Agency of Education under the governor’s thumb.
The quality of Vermont’s schools has slipped, and we know it. We are only as good as the people who lead us. If the state’s minimal effort to search for a new leader doesn’t produce a top tier candidate, the search should be reopened. If it costs more than $495 for a successful search, then that $2.56 billion “company” -us-should spring for it.
It’s embarrassing to have to make such a suggestion; but here we are.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here