The task of a Sunset Advisory Commission is defensible if for no other reason than it breaks inertia, which should be a consideration in state government just as it is in business, or most any other venture. It’s the impetus that forces creativity.
It’s in that vein that members of the board are putting together language for the Legislature to consider that would “sunset” the State Board of Education.
Sen. Jeanette White, D-Windham, and co-chair of the commission, was quoted as saying: “I think we should be bold. I don’t think we should not recommend something just because it’ll be a political mine field.”
And the commission should be bold, so long as it’s understood that the outcome produces something better than what we have. It doesn’t work for “bold” to simply be for the board to disappear, its mission folded into the Agency of Education, the opportunity for vision forgotten.
The opportunity presents itself as an extension of the move in 2012 to have the Secretary of Education be a job appointed by the governor, not the board of education. With that change also came the change in administrative duties, something now focused within the agency, and away from the board.
As recognized by chair of the board, John Carroll, the responsibilities of the board today are far different than they were prior to 2012. He made note of such when he asked board members to consider the change in mission. “We [the board] are in a unique position to shape the future of education in Vermont. But to do so, we need to kind of get up on the hillside.”
He’s correct. And the timing is pivotal.
Vermont’s educational system has long been regarded as one of the nation’s best, but that reputation is at risk; we spend more per student than almost any other states, but our results don’t rank at the same level. A good part of this challenge has to do with demographics and our battle with a dramatic decline in student numbers, which has been followed by a change in resources and direction. But part of our present condition could also include a three-part educational system: early education, preK-12, and higher education. What we should have is an educational system that is early childhood through college [including certificate programs, CCV, tech schools, etc.] Instead, we have a siloed system, each devoted to protecting its own turf.
We no longer have the resources to act and to think separately. We haven’t for years. The task of the board of education could be to figure out how a single educational system could work and to identify all the pieces and the parties responsible for them. It might stun us to learn how many different educational programs there are within the different agencies and how little one communicates with the other.
That might require a different board since the objective would be broader and more encompassing. And care would need to be exercised in terms of the board’s authority. In fact, it’s debatable as to how much real power the board should have. The objective would be to give it enough power to be effective without giving it so much power that it corrupts. That’s a delicate dance.
But an improved educational system, from diapers to degree, is the state’s primary objective. We’re only as good as what we teach. If we are to be honest with ourselves we know our reach has not exceeded our grasp. Not close.
If the Sunset Advisory Commission, the Legislature, and the chairman of the State Board of Education are looking for change in direction, and an elevated purpose, this pursuit would more than qualify.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here