It’s a battle few understand, a battle that affects all Vermonters, and a battle that constitutes 20 percent of the state’s gross domestic product. It’s also a battle that has largely escaped notice, or at least serious attention, by those running for office and the state’s press corps.
The issue is the cost of health care and the authority of the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] to control how our healthcare system operates and what our hospitals and insurers can charge for their services.
The battle was launched this week when the University of Vermont Medical Center said it would file a motion to overturn GMCB’s order that UVM exceeded its net patient revenue numbers by $80 million in Fiscal 2023, The filing also challenges the board’s order to force the hospital to reduce the commercial insurance rates it can charge by one percent in FY25.
The state’s largest hospital also argues that the board denied the hospital its chance to offer any testimony in defense of its budget or a full accounting of why the $80 million in “excess” spending was justified.
GMCB responded in kind, denying UVM’s claims making it clear the hospital was not only in error but said the violations “resulted in unnecessary and excessive costs to Vermonters.” The board’s statement concluded: “As repeatedly made clear to UVMMC, GMCB’s budget decision was not a penalty and UVMMC did not avail itself of opportunities to address its excessive revenue.”
The fault line is clear. UVM contends it cannot provide the necessary medical services to its patients if it is not given the money to do so. The GMCB contends Vermonters will be priced out of their ability to afford health care if hospitals and insurance companies have their budgets approved no matter the request. The board also says its cost control responsibilities are for naught if UVM’s healthcare network isn’t an example of this necessary prudence. [UVM represents more than half of the state’s healthcare expenditures.]
It’s unclear when the GMCB will hear UVM’s appeal, but it’s assumed it will be sooner rather than later. Even if the regulator agreed to allow UVM another chance to explain its need, it’s far from certain the board would change its mind.
Still, it’s a case that every hospital CEO in Vermont will be watching. Vermont’s hospitals have been put on notice that their futures are being challenged by financial and well as demographic issues, yet medical inflation continues to take its toll. How the GMCB responds to UVM’s plea will send a clear message to the state’s healthcare community, including its insurers.
UVM has made the first move by notifying the public through press releases that it is beginning to cut services, including its notice that it would pause construction of its planned outpatient surgical center. The hospital’s outreach is fairly limited. If it begins a public relations campaign to that effect - cutting services to would-be patients - that could be a game changer.
The same applies to the GMCB. If it steps beyond press releases to a public campaign of its own, all based on the need for an affordable healthcare system, that, too, would be compelling.
Perhaps such campaigns would engage not only the public, but the legislators who represent us. No longer can we pretend that we have a system in place that offers a high level of care at a price that is anywhere close to being affordable. No longer can we pretend that Vermonters are being given the necessary information about their respective healthcare systems to know whether their communities, and the state, are being well served.
It’s a neglected conversation because it’s one without easy answers. We defer the conversation because it involves change and potential pain. That’s why, in part, we are witness to a battle that has opened before us. We’ve deferred too long. Now, we have no choice.
If it’s to end well we will need to communicate much better than we have. And with dispatch.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here