A commonsense step for school budget crisis

Posted

To most Vermonters, this legislative session will be known as the one that took a chunk out of their pocketbooks. Fair or not, when homeowners see their property tax bills not only will they lament the damage to their bank accounts, they will look for someone to blame, which will be the people they elect to act in the voters’ best interest.

The damage will be less than first feared [in the 20 percent range] but in the most recent version of the education funding bill passed by the Senate, the number will be closer to 12.5 percent.

That’s still a boatload of money to most Vermonters. It’s also not a one-time property tax increase, something that might be erased. It’s part of the base. A forever increase.

Which prompts voters to ask what’s next? What stops this train?

Legislators were able to reduce the percentage increase by pumping $25 million in one-time money into the education fund. They also added two new taxes for another $27 million. On the cost containment front, the Senate bill also lowers the excess spending threshold from 20 percent to 16 percent for those schools spending above the state average.

All that helped, but still left the expected increase unacceptably high. The bill has yet to be finalized but Gov. Phil Scott has already assured legislators he will veto the bill unless meaningful changes are made, which is next to impossible. The Democrats have enough votes to override his veto but are understandably leery of the potential repercussions in the voting booth in November.

The excuse for the present-day circumstance is that legislators didn’t have the time to vet the issue and propose a meaningful change in how our schools are funded. When the administration notified legislators in December that school spending would result in a 20 percent property tax increase, the governor was accused of being an alarmist. 

Clearly, he wasn’t. A third of our schools had their budgets beaten on Town Meeting Day. And, legislators of all political stripes are acknowledging the depth of the challenge.

We’re still at that crisis point. Not only do we still have schools without approved budgets, we have schools in desperate need of money to fix dilapidated buildings. The same pressures that forced school spending up this year are still in place, i.e., health insurance, labor contracts, etc. 

This year’s circumstances are not a one-year issue.

Legislators understand the need to stem the bleeding and to figure out new and better ways to pay for our schools, an arduous process. But the key element missing in any strategy being considered is one of timely information, specifically, from our schools. 

Typically, school boards tie up their budgets late in the year or in the months just prior to Town Meeting Day. That leaves little time for the Legislature to react before it adjourns eight weeks later.

The truth of the matter is that schools know today what next year’s budget will be. Perhaps not to the penny but close enough. Any group tasked with exploring how to address our school spending issues should ask all schools for that preliminary information now. It’s ridiculous to put a study committee in the position of dreaming up a new structure when it doesn’t know what it’s up against.

If, for example, we had known in May 2023 that school spending pressures would trigger a 20 percent hike in property taxes almost a year later, would that not have been enough time to figure out a meaningful response?

Of course, it would.

And wouldn’t such an extended timeline lessen the political acrimony that comes with last-second choices and contentious negotiation? 

This will not lessen the pain of what’s coming our way this year, but going forward why not take the commonsense step of informing ourselves in time to be prudent in our decisions?

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here