A 12% hike in your property tax bill? Again?

Posted

Every December 1st, the Department of Taxes issues a letter forecasting what Vermonters will pay in property taxes to fund our schools. It used to be that the letter was accepted for what it is, a forecast, nothing more. That nonchalance changed with the department’s letter on Dec. 1, 2023, which forecast a stunning 18.5 percent increase. The final tally was 13.8 percent, a number that still outraged voters and cost Democrats 18 seats in the House and six seats in the Senate in the 2024 general election.

We may be looking at round two.

On Monday, the department released its expected letter forecasting a 12 percent increase in property tax bills for residents. If that number prevails, Vermonters would have seen their property tax bills jump 41 percent over the last five years.

That’s not likely to happen for two reasons: first, school boards have yet to finalize their budgets, and it’s a decent bet they will be asking their superintendents to come in with reduced budgets; second, the 2024 election was a disaster for Democrats, and they are highly unlikely to be put in the same situation again. Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth, Monday, responded to the 12 percent increase by saying “this pattern absolutely cannot continue” and he promised to “advance reforms that will foster an equitable education system for all of Vermont’s children at a price that’s affordable, predictable and stable for Vermont’s families.”

The tax department’s letter comes following the School Redistricting Task Force’s decision to disregard Gov. Phil Scott’s proposal to reduce the state’s 119 school districts into a few large ones. The task force instead voted to pursue a plan for voluntary mergers through “Cooperative Education Service Areas,” contending that the governor’s plan did not guarantee lower costs or improved educational outcomes. The governor said the redistricting committee “failed” in its job and showed no regard for the continued increase in educational costs.

There is no question that Mr. Scott controls the narrative with his continued push toward affordability. The tax department’s 12 percent forecast will only accentuate it. And we won’t know for certain what the property tax increase will be until all school budgets are voted on, which won’t be until late in the session.

The Legislature has faced this issue twice in the last two years and has opted to funnel millions of General Fund dollars into the education fund, essentially buying down the original property tax increase. In 2023, that spending reduced the 18.5 percent number down to 13.8 percent. In 2024, the Legislature agreed to spend $118 million in General Fund dollars to reduce the increase from 5.9 percent down to 1.1 percent.

They could do that again [at great cost], but the money is still coming from taxpayers, just not in the form of a property tax bill. Obviously, the options are becoming fewer. If the country slips into a recession, the available dollars will quickly shrink.

What the tax department’s 12 percent forecast has done is to force the Legislature into sharpening its focus. Whereas the redistricting task force [established as part of Act 73] has opted for a different approach than the governor, there is still much the law proposes, including a new weighted student funding formula, class size minimums, restrictions on private school tuition, funding for school construction costs, and statewide graduation requirements.

What the Legislature can’t do [without putting the Democrats at risk next November] is to pretend voters are oblivious to the pending property tax increase. They aren’t. And they may be reluctant to spend $100 million or much more to buy down the property tax increase.

We are at the point where the obvious can’t be ignored. We have schools too small to be efficiently run; a plan needs to be put in place to close them. We continue to lose students and have the lowest student-to-teacher ratio in the nation. Labor makes up 80 percent of a school’s operating costs, so we obviously need to reduce the number of teachers. We continue to pass legislation that obligates schools to expand their responsibilities without the funding to support it. If, for example, we scaled back social services efforts in schools, that would save millions.

Each decision would require some political capital to be spent. But the options are quickly vanishing. Vermont is experiencing two things at the same time: it’s being recognized as a state with one of the nation’s highest educational costs, and a state whose academic standing has plummeted. We’ve done nothing to address either challenge.

That’s not acceptable. Our legislators and the governor need to figure out how to use the tax department’s letter to Vermont’s advantage.

By Emerson Lynn

 

 

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here