In January 2025, a “working group” - yet unnamed - will deliver to the Legislature a plan to deal with the state’s $6 billion school construction needs.
Let’s hope these are paid positions.
[Just kidding. Sorta of.]
The working group proposal is included in the recommendations offered to the Legislature this week by the School Construction Aid Task Force. The mission was to investigate how the state could step into the school construction arena after a 17-year absence. The report is daunting and largely a replay of the damage caused by indefensible procrastination.
The headline from the report is a list of five numbers:
$228,613,264 in immediate needs - “…failed systems or issues of health, safety or security…”
$341,424,888 in 1-to-2 year needs.
$904,680,288 in 3-5 year needs.
$1,426,800,696 in 6-10 year needs.
$3,450,805,816 in 10-20 year needs.
The $6 billion total is an acknowledged underestimate if things remain as is. But even the $228 million in “immediate” need is a heavy lift. Add another $341 million needed within the next year or two, and you quickly realize how undoable the task is. We don’t move that fast. Not close. Yet, if we don’t, that half-billion dollar cost multiplies.
That sense of urgency prompted the Task Force to hint at the obvious: It’s irresponsible to consider all of Vermont’s 384 school buildings as a group that needs to be repaired and sustained. School buildings can be valuable assets for communities. They all don’t need to be kept as schools.
The Task force urged that the Joint Fiscal Office model a variety of financial options to see which arrangement might be most suitable. There is also the need to explore different revenue sources: “The Task Force recommends that both upfront incentives and annual debt service subsidy aid are best served by an ongoing annual funding source.”
Another heavy lift. Vermont is strained now. What other sources of revenue are there that have not already been tapped and are big enough to meet school construction needs?
To identify such funding and to propose its implementation will carry an obvious political cost.
However, the most important recommendation made by the Task Force had less to do with funding than the decision-making required to ensure the course set was defensible.The Task Force said before anything happens that the “governance framework must come first.”
That means figuring out which schools need to be consolidated with other nearby schools. It means deciding how best to resize Vermont’s educational system so that there are a reasonable number of students per teacher. Reasonable is another way of saying affordable. What we have now isn’t. We can’t rebuild all that we have.
Choosing which school needs to be closed or repurposed could be essential to how Vermont strengthens its educational system. It’s also perhaps the heaviest political lift in Vermont. If done correctly anyone on that working group will make more enemies than friends.
We are in this position because we put off what needed to be done, which was to keep our schools in good repair. The question now is whether there is the leadership necessary to push forward and to give the necessary support to those asked to serve.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here