50 years later, is Act 250 going to be changed?

Posted

It was 56 years ago that Act 250 was passed, the state’s regulatory weapon to deal with the ill effects of unchecked growth that, in the 1960s, put the state’s identity at risk. Part of that regulatory oversight was to do a better job of equalizing the power of the public with the power of developers. Vermonters needed to be able to say no to development. 

Today, more than half a century later, there is a push to lessen Act 250’s grip on development, housing in particular. What was true in 1970, when Act 250 became law, is no longer applicable. The need for housing is acute, and Act 250 is viewed as part of the problem. Opponents to a development have learned how to use the law to slow a project down, if not kill it outright. The legal process adds huge costs to housing that is already expensive.

At long last, the need for housing has become so critical that the invincibility of Act 250 has been pierced. We’re able to talk about changing the law without people thinking the church’s rafters are about to collapse. 

When the Legislature convenes, one of those changes is a proposal to consider ways to limit the ability of opponents to appeal new development by taking the appeals process out of the court system and placing it under the purview of the Land Use Review Board, the central component of H.687 that was signed into law on June 17, 2024.

The Legislature had to override Gov. Phil Scott’s veto to make it law. Mr. Scott thought the bill did not go far enough and that it could hurt, not help, development in the state’s rural areas. The governor was right, and the move to shift the appeals process out of the courts and into the Land Use Review Board is part of the gradual move away from Act 250’s grip.

Since the law’s passage 18 months ago, the fervor for change has intensified. With the exception of some environmental groups, the political alignment of both parties appears pointed in the direction of change. 

Miro Weinberger, a Democrat and former Mayor of the City of Burlington, was quoted as saying, “The fact that our appeals system is so broken is perhaps the largest remaining regulatory barrier to having a housing system that will meet the state’s needs.” Mr. Weomberger is also the executive chair of Let’s Build Homes, a pro-housing advocacy organization.

When a Democrat of Mr. Weinberger’s pedigree starts rallying against Act 250’s regulatory purpose, you know things have changed, or are about to. 

That doesn’t mean the fight is over. There are still many who don’t want the change, who don’t want development, and who think developers sell snake oil on the side. Some of these folks represent us in the Legislature.

But their numbers are dwindling. Common sense is having a moment in the sunlight. The deleterious effect of being 40,000 housing units short of where we need to be is demonstrably obvious.

Act 250 was one of the defining marks of Gov. Dean Davis gubernatorial years. Was he wrong? No. Not for what ailed Vermont in the 1960s and ‘70s.  But a half-century later, Vermont’s needs have changed. Dramatically. We can’t continue to pair the past with the future. Change needs to be viewed as a virtue, not a capitulation. We don’t need the billboards, but we do need the new homes. A lot of them.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here