Bernie's fight with Big Food

Posted

Bernie Sanders Thursday jabbed his rhetorical thumb into the gut of the food and beverage industry, blaming them for America’s obesity and diabetes epidemic. Vermont’s senior senator’s ire is appropriate. As chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, the hope is that he will make this into a crusade that shakes the status quo out of its oblivion.

This issue goes far beyond the “soak the rich” spiel associated with Mr. Sanders. Americans are force-fed an ultra-processed diet loaded with sugar, salt and saturated fat. As the senator noted in his remarks, it’s a diet “purposely designed to be overeaten.”

The consequences are enormous. Not only are Americans less healthy, the cost of treating diabetes in 2022 was $413 billion, a 27 percent jump over the last half decade. The Center for Disease Control estimates that over the next 40 years there will be a 700 percent increase in the type-2 diabetes among children. Becoming a diabetic as a child is a strong predictor of not only a shortened life but a substantial increase in cost to the health care system.

That cost is massive. Today, we spend in excess of $4.3 trillion on health care, or roughly $13,000 for every man, woman and child. That total is about double what other developed countries spend. Our health care outcomes are no better, and in many cases worse.

If the rising cost of health care is a factor of an aging population that needs more care, that would be one thing, but it’s not. The lion’s share of our health care costs are “chronic health care” needs, which, by definition, means something that can be controlled. Chronic care costs represent about 84 cents for every dollar spent on health care. 

Mr. Sanders’s point is that an indefensible percentage of that chronic care cost is obesity, which, in turn, can be dumped into the lap of the food and beverage industry.

The irony, of course, is that our government subsidizes many of the crops that end up in the labs/kitchens of the food and beverage industry, which explains why broccoli is more expensive than potato chips.

The senator wants the food and beverage industry to be banned from advertising to children. That is a start. But what the senator should do is figure out a way to force the industries to account for what they have cost our health care system, similar to what the tobacco companies were required to pay out when they could no longer deny the harm of their products.

It would also be highly beneficial to the cause if Mr. Sanders embraced the need to stress the value of prevention versus treatment. One of the unspoken truths of our health care system is that there is no money in wellness, only in sickness. That has to be turned on its head. This is one of the reasons to support OneCare Vermont. Its payment reform effort to shift from fee-for-service to a capitation payment system is one way to incentivize the system to reduce costs by focusing on what is necessary to make the population healthier.

Is this an issue in Vermont, and elsewhere?

Absolutely. Less than a decade ago RiseVt - a locally started, and now defunct, health care prevention initiative - conducted back-to-back surveys of every first, third and fifth grader in Franklin and Grand Isle counties. The result was stunning. Of that cohort 41 percent were overweight or obese. The odds are overwhelming that a decade later those children are among the ones Mr. Sanders was referring to in talking about how obesity often translates into diabetes.

What’s being done about it?

Not a thing.

Not only does the food and beverage industry owe the American public a big check to the states’ health care systems for what it has cost us, Mr. Sanders should use his bully pulpit to campaign for the obvious: There is money in wellness. Every dollar NOT spent on health care is a dollar that can be saved. It is also a more humane way to live.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here