ST. ALBANS CITY — At around 3 p.m. on May 19 – roughly 130 years ago – “the most disastrous conflagration which has ever visited Vermont” came to St. Albans.
“Most of the buildings were of wood, and burned like tinder before the strong gale, with many occupants not having time to save their effects,” a 19th-century reporter wrote for the San Francisco Call.
The destruction didn’t last long, however. Despite $500,000 in estimated damages (in 1895 dollars), St. Albans residents rebuilt its downtown in less than a decade. As newspapers at the time noted, half of it was insured.
“Vermont was growing like crazy, and (the railroad) was hiring people left and right,” architect Laz Scangas said, in a recent talk about the era. “They had like 3,000 people they were using just in the yards.”
Now close to 130 years past the moment, it’s hard to imagine what 19th century St. Albans could have been like, but a presentation by Scangas – delivered together with history expert Lyssa Papazian at the Preservation Trust of Vermont’s historic preservation conference – gave some insights into the challenges Vermont’s former generations faced trying to establish downtown St. Albans – with one major caveat.
“The one thing I have to say, in all my research, and I asked all these sources, I cannot find one photo of the buildings being rebuilt,” Scangas said.
Sebastian Cerny spent a good portion of this early summer on a four-story scaffold perched outside the top floor of 45 Kingman St.
The structure, known for its atypical castle-like appearance, needed some repairs to better secure some masonry near the top of the building. Passersbys have likely noted the huge stone sculptures – removed via crane – now sitting on the property’s side lawn waiting for re-installation.
Owner Jim Cameron secured roughly $100,000 in state historic revitalization grants paired with some federal tax credits to help cover the roughly $300,000 in repair costs needed for the south wall dormer reconstruction. Hawk & Trowel Restorations and Masonry, one of the state’s premier masonry businesses based out of Richmond, ended up getting the contract, and Cerny was part of the crew brought in to help.
“I was fairly green when I started,” he explained as he chipped away at a brick. “I just had a little bit of carpentry experience. I met Tom, and we hit it off. He was just starting his business back up a few years ago, and so I got on board, and he's been teaching me everything he knows for the past few years.”
Their goal? To restore the former courthouse as well as they could using similar techniques. The mortar, for example, had to be analyzed and reconstructed, Cameron said, which adds to the costs, and masons have had to be careful to restore its facade to match the original stone. 45 Kingman St’s marble shell sits on top of a brick wall with additional terracotta to help prevent the building from burning down.
It was also one of the few buildings on Kingman Street that survived the 1895 fire, which was by far the most destructive in St. Albans history.
According to Scangas and Papazian’s research, downtown St. Albans suffered three big fires in the latter half of the 19th century before it professionalized its fire services and installed water lines throughout the downtown to better curb big fires. As a result, buildings in downtown St. Albans are largely a hodgepodge of architectural styles spanning decades.
By age, the oldest are the string of buildings on Main Street just north of Taylor Park. The older architectural styles – many pre-dating the Civil War – reflect the earlier time period before St. Albans commercial corridor was rebuilt with mostly brick.
Historical photos collected by Scangas show how downtown St. Albans looked in that time period. Instead of the wall-to-wall lines of brick buildings, the place had many more wooden structures reminiscent of old-timey saloons, with their porches, hitching posts and slanting roofs.
Today, you’re much more likely to find brick storefronts, arched windows and flat roofs. Some changes happened more naturally as owners often rebuilt their structures or upgraded them as breakdowns occurred. The downtown fires, however, often required larger-scale blockwide reconstructions.
The first big fire, for example, occurred in 1871 and burned down roughly 25 buildings near Lake Street. While both the St. Albans House and the American House were constructed prior to the fire, they saw upgrades after the fire ran through town when the buildings were repaired.
The other large fires occurred in 1891 and 1895. To trace the lines of their destruction, Papazian dug through historic photos and found evidence to better clarify when various buildings would pop up or disappear, helping to paint a timeline of breakdown and reconstruction, and giving today’s planners a better idea of just why downtown is laid out like it was.
A good example is the iconic “Three Ladies” fountain in Taylor Park. Roughly 150 years ago, downtown’s Welden House Hotel located just north of Taylor Park featured 200 rooms arranged in a five-story tall edifice. Known as the best-equipped summer resort in the region, it likely attracted a wide range of dignitaries coming down to visit local businessmen and community leaders.
“People came here because they were doing business with the railroad and the Smiths and the Branons. There were certain people who were moneymakers in St. Albans,” Scangas said.
The details help paint the picture. Down the street, from his office tower at the Central Valley Railroad headquarters, the elderly John G. Smith – Vermont’s former “war governor” and railroad magnate – could look down on his growing empire as he prepared his son Edward for the job.
Just a walk up the block, he dined with financiers and politicians from the region’s premier hotel with a beautiful promenade in Taylor Park just outside, reminiscent of the finest European parks. In 1887, Smith donated the “Three Ladies” sculpture to sit as its centerpiece, located within sight of the stately hotel.
But even this arrangement would disappear. The Welden House burned down in the summer of 1897, and by the turn of the century, Smith’s old railroad empire around Kingman Street would also be substantially altered after 130 buildings were burned to the ground due to the 1895 conflagration.
To show what the 19th century looked like, Scangas leaned on the work of photographer W.D. Chandler, who operated out of the top story of 54 Kingman St.. He would have likely seen the reconstruction being less than a block away, but Scangas said he couldn’t find any photographic evidence to show how St. Albans was rebuilt so quickly.
Either way, they must have had the resources because the work got done. Fire insurance maps depicting Kingman Street show how the layout changed significantly in just a few years.
Scangas said they likely used the old foundations of the prior buildings to finish it more efficiently. St. Albans prior masons and bricklayers, too, may have specialized in certain techniques, which became repeated architectural motifs for the larger city.
“We don’t know an awful lot about the brick masons who were working at this time, but I suspect they knew how to do their arches and their canted corners.” Papazian said.
A breakdown of the population can give some insight. Altogether, St. Albans would have had roughly half of its total people today, but the city population would have been more densely populated in their rows of houses.
The demographic makeup was also substantially different, consisting of more families and more children. According to the 1890 Census, one third of Franklin County’s roughly 30,000 residents were under the age of 21, compared to today’s roughly one fourth of the population, with a tendency for people – especially non-landowners – to congregate in city centers.
There was also a more dynamic mix of foreign peoples, as the available railroad work and surrounding agricultural economy would attract a mix of skilled and unskilled laborers. Roughly one-in-six, too, according to Census numbers, would have been French-Canadian, with about half of total residents being direct descendants of immigrants, including some Irish, English and German. Over time, they eventually re-made Vermont into their own.
Lots of things have happened in the time since the big 1895 fire. Electrification, Vermont’s tourism craze in the mid-20th century and the establishment of the interstate system have been huge game-changers, and they’ve rewritten many of the trendlines which guided the state. The railroads, for example, had to change dramatically when cars became the de-facto transportation choice for the majority of Vermonters.
St. Albans City, however, can still point to its older buildings – like 45 Kingman St. – as a continuing connection to the time before all that happened, when Vermont was still laying the foundations of today’s modern world.
“There were a lot of contractors working at the time,” Papazian said. “And they were all building at the same time … this incredible variety of these buildings that were all built in five years.”
“And you’re talking about bricks. Think of the number of bricks that were needed,” Scangas added. “You’re talking about millions of bricks. How did they keep all of that supply?”
--
For more information, Scangas' presentation can be found below.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here