Withstanding the moment: Franklin County reacts to 2024 election cycle

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — On the outskirts of St. Albans Town, Tammy Hetrick used to feel comfortable staking political signs in her front lawn. Then 2024 hit.

“I just think it is so much worse than it was in 2016 or in 2020,” Hetrick said. “I miss my conservative friends.”

For the last four years, Hetrick said there’s been very little chit-chat among her neighbors and there’s been tension among friends along political lines.

Dan Pipes on the other hand doesn’t see it. A resident of Fairfield, he doesn’t think small-town America is as divided as national figures make it out to be.

“Honestly, I'm kind of puzzled,” he said. “I do not see Nazis or white supremacists lurking around every corner, and I don't see Marxists and Communists. I think people need to just step back from the rhetoric and speak to each other as neighbors and human beings.”

“I believe we have checks and balances and safeguards in place that will weather the storm,” he added. “What makes you believe we can’t withstand this particular moment?”

In the run up to Election Day next Tuesday, people seem to be divided about whether the country is divided — and if that doesn’t paint a picture five days before the presidential election, what does?

Finding solutions

In the 50 years local journalist Richard Cowperthwait has been covering politics in Franklin County, this is the first year he’s seen so many uncontested races.

“I’m struck by just how few candidates there are,” he said. “It’s the first time in half a century there isn’t a contested state senate race. That’s unbelievable.”

To him, that says the tension at the national level has trickled down, leaving folks discouraged and uninterested in local lawmaking. The rhetoric, too, has reached another level, creating repackaged talking points meant to break through the noise.

“Everybody's screaming about property taxes, but I haven't seen a lot of really well-articulated plans out there,” Hetrick said, who classifies herself as “socially left and fiscally moderate.”

Pipes, who said he is “socially and fiscally conservative,” feels similarly. He wants to talk seriously about Vermont’s education system, and its ripple effect to taxes, demographics and workforce.

“People say taxes are ridiculous because of the schools, and that’s pretty much where the conversation starts and ends,” he said. “How do we fix this? I really don’t think people in Franklin County have been putting critical thought into it.”

Both Hetrick and Pipes are politically plugged-in. As members of the Franklin County chapter of Braver Angels, a national nonprofit that seeks to unite conservatives and progressives, they are well-versed on the issues and personally know local lawmakers.

They both seek out candidates to speak with them one-on-one, rather than relying on campaign mailers or press appearances. Hetrick said she particularly likes visiting each party’s tent at Franklin County Field Days.

Pipes thinks that in-person connection is unique to rural towns, and he doesn’t take it for granted. “That’s a luxury,” he said.

And though those one-on-one conversations may be more in-depth, Pipes and Hetrick still aren’t hearing the solutions they seek.

During the conversations Cowperthwait has with candidates on Northwest Access TV, he tries to probe at those solutions with the questions he asks, but he’s found the problems still get the majority of the airtime.

“There’s plenty to criticize out there, but what are your thoughts? Have you got some ideas?” he said.

Student point-of-view

Candidates running for office use a range of methods to get their message out. Those who do have opponents have spent the last weeks sign-waving at busy intersections, mailing postcards to area homes, speaking to the press and participating in community forums — all in an effort to win the vote.

Those responsible for informing the public, too, also spend plenty of time coordinating and collecting information. This past Monday, St. Albans City School sixth-graders held their own legislative forum to talk to the four candidates running for two representative seats.

Finn Sturm, the moderator for the night, said he wanted to know a little more about the politicians’ viewpoints on environmentalism and housing.

“I only really know a lot in depth about one of the candidates,” he said. “So I'm definitely hoping to learn more about, not only personality, but definitely their political views and everything.”

Similarly, Sierra Trombley had come equipped with a few facts about public safety, and Autumn Krans, meanwhile, had a question about school shootings after Essex had a shutdown earlier this month. They were both hoping to get some insights into tackling the two issues.

During the event, the students took turns asking their questions and candidates had opportunities to respond. Sturm, like any good moderator, mixed up who he asked the questions to as the night went along.

Plenty of adults sat in the audience, too, listening quietly with arms crossed while taking in each answer in the school library.

Where do we go from here?

Both Hetrick and Pipes have different solutions for healing the tensions of this moment.

While Hetrick thinks a specific presidential result will help, what she really wants is for everyone to operate from the same set of facts. Right now, she doesn’t know where people are getting their information, and there are plenty of untrustworthy sources blatantly spraying falsehoods on the Internet.

“Everybody needs to get their news from the same place, and then if you want to go to your forums and say how you feel about it, [that’s] fine,” she said.

A collective focus around reading and watching the local news again, could be what sparks Hetrick and her neighbors to wave to each other again. She said it's been too long.

For Pipes, not making politics the center of every community conversation could be the answer.

“One of the least interesting things about people, for me, is their political leaning. It's way down on my list,” Pipes said. “I much prefer to talk to people about what makes them happy and what their goals are and what they want for their children.”

“We make politics larger than it should be in our lives,” he added.

Perhaps a better start might be leaving it to the sixth-graders. While many were nervous standing before the crowd Monday night (and some were likely there for the assignment), they had come out to engage in the process without any preconceived notions, asking their questions to see who they’d like to best vote for.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here