When will the housing crisis end? 3 scenarios that could provide the way out

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — 200 housing units in the works for downtown St. Albans. Another 30 for seniors coming to Highgate, and dozens coming online throughout rural Franklin County.

And yet, housing costs keep going up. The median price for new homes in Vermont increased by 11% year-over-year, helping to make 2023 the worst year in the last decade for home sales in the state, according to an analysis by the Vermont Housing Finance Agency.

It’s difficult to overstate Vermont’s ongoing housing problem.  

The combination of high construction costs, increased interest rates and regulatory burden has created an undersupply of housing stock in Vermont, and the problem has only produced additional bottlenecks affecting the state’s workforce and tax revenues. To tackle the problem, the State of Vermont has pledged millions of dollars and work-hours. 

But will the statewide effort succeed in pushing down housing costs for your average Vermonter? 

Experts are hopeful, but it’s likely something will need change before Vermont shakes the status quo. What happens first, however, will likely determine the years ahead.

After taking a look at the trendlines and talking to experts, the Messenger wanted to know what the future of Vermont’s housing crisis could look like and better understand what can be done today to solve the issue.

Here are three scenarios that could drive the next stage of Vermont’s housing crisis.

Scenario 1: Interest rates drop

The Federal Reserve began raising interest rates in March 2022, and since that time, Vermont’s housing market has cooled to the point where now it’s starting to harden. The number of new homes sold in 2023 was the lowest in a decade, according to a statewide analysis by the Vermont Housing Finance Authority.

Lowering interest rates back down could, in theory, revitalize Vermont’s market, Champlain Housing Trust executive director Michael Monte said. Bringing mortgage rates from today’s 7% back to the 4.4% set before the reserve’s increase would also help cut down on monthly costs for new homeowners.

“A big change will be when interest rates go down, because I think it has impacts on what we’re doing,” Monte said. “It’s nothing different than having more money.”

By lowering interest rates, Monte said developers and investors can likely get more bang for their buck, thereby lowering the overall cost of development. That in turn could build more housing, which would then increase the supply. More supply, in theory, equals lower demand and lower costs for consumers. 

“From a systems perspective, the interest rate has to go down at the federal level. That’s a tell for me that people struggling out there will be able to do some things better and faster,” Monte said.

The likelihood of the feds making the change? Who knows.

The Federal Reserve communicated its intention to keep rates close to current high levels throughout 2024 just this week, and while the institution forecasted three rate cuts for this year in March, its newest set of economic projections dropped the forecasted rate cuts for this year down to one. 

The next time Vermonters will know is when the Federal Reserve meets in September. By then, another busy real estate season will have been left in the dust. 

If interest rates are lowered at that point, however, Monte isn’t so sure that Vermont’s housing crisis would disappear anytime soon. Lower-income people without the ability to save up  – including many of today’s renters considered cost-burdened by housing – wouldn’t see relief from Vermont’s already-inflated rental market, continuing the decades-long trend of pushing younger Vermonters out of homeownership. Instead, current property owners, especially those double-income households who bought prior to COVID-19, would be in a much better financial position to take advantage of the new stock over their neighbors.

“If interest gets better, it’s only going to meet the needs of the middle income folks, and maybe not even that,” Monte said. “Those two-person incomes making between $100,000 to $200,000, they’ll be fine. They can afford a car and build up a nest egg.”

The 2022 Housing Needs Assessment of Northwest Vermont estimated that roughly 3 in 4 people making less than median income in Franklin and Grand Isle counties are cost-burdened by housing, meaning they were spending more than 30% of their income. The assessment noted that individuals in these groups tend to be younger and living alone.

Lowering interest rates could also help eliminate the “golden handcuff” effect that is likely stopping some older residents from downsizing. The term references the financial reason that older buyers have to avoid higher interest rates, especially if they purchased their prior home at the historically low rates available post-recession.

“My frustration is that things can’t happen faster,” Monte said. “It’s not that we don't have the opportunities to resolve issues, but they can’t happen faster.”

Scenario 2: State intervention

The latest housing bill to make it out of the state legislature in the past year – H.687 – makes changes to how Act 250 functions, sets up additional place-based tiers to guide development and creates additional protections for ecologically sensitive areas.

Gov. Phil Scott, however, isn’t so sure about the bill. It was delivered to his desk last week for his signature, but Scott has been outspoken in his concerns about the bill’s impacts, pointing to the effects the legislative changes to the Act 250 process will have on rural areas. He contests that upon passage, H.687 would “make it harder to build housing units in most parts of the state.”

“I believe rural Vermonters deserve affordable housing as much as those from Burlington and Montpelier. H. 687 suggests otherwise and sets the state up for years of inaction, at a time when we need to move swiftly to support the housing needs of all Vermonters,” Scott said in a statement released back in March. 

Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City) has a much more positive take on the bill, and he pushed back against Scott’s summation, pointing out that the changes made in H.687 will likely boost housing initiatives over the next few years. 

“Changes in regulatory policy can have the biggest impacts on the market,” McCarthy said. “I think there’s a sense that the government’s not doing anything, but we have all these mechanisms working together to try to fix a market failure that in its modern form dates back to the Great Recession.”

Only time will tell exactly who has the right idea, but both sides of the political argument have focused on regulatory reform as a way out of the housing crisis. 

The big difference is that Republicans have tied the housing crisis to Vermont’s larger affordability problem, which includes higher property taxes. They’ve also been some of the General Assembly’s loudest critics.

“We need to get as many housing units online as possible,” Rep. Casey Toof (R-St. Albans Town) said. “If you want to solve property taxes, the workforce shortage to bring people in and the crisis of rent and housing costs, put more units on the market.

“How do we get there? It’s very tough.”

Over the last few years, the General Assembly has largely spent its time trying to re-work Act 250, Vermont’s monumental land use bill, but McCarthy said there’s also room to improve the individual zoning codes of each municipality. 

One of the largest difficulties associated with getting houses built, McCarthy said, has been the public outcry that often comes with new development, commonly referred to as NIMBYism to match the acronym of Not-In-My-Back-Yard.

“For all the desire that the public and policymakers have to build more housing, in each of our communities, there are people saying ‘Don’t build places next to me,’” McCarthy said. “That story is told hundreds and hundreds of times across Vermont. There is a general desire for there to be a house or apartment available nearby, but so many policy barriers in place.”

In St. Albans, for example, residents visited Monday’s City Council meeting to bring up concerns around public safety in downtown. For both the Lake Apartments and Reid Commons buildings currently under construction, residents asked who exactly was expected to move in.

“Many of them are working individuals – individuals who work at Ben & Jerry’s or Berry Callebaut,  LNAs at the hospital, teachers being hired,” Mayor Tim Smith said. “This has been an ongoing discussion with the owner to make sure he’s aware of what our concerns are, and that will continue as well.”

Meanwhile, a large reason that construction of the Lake Street apartment project was able to move forward in the first place was because the state loaned close to $8 million toward the project to center affordable housing in the west side of St. Albans. The census tract that covers the city’s west side is one of only two places in Franklin County where at least half of households would qualify to live in those apartments under the state’s loan requirements. 

Under H.687, McCarthy said the place-based jurisdiction requirements would help streamline the process in which NIMBY concerns are heard by creating better-defined categories on where larger buildings can be constructed in Vermont. The new process removes some local control from residents living in more urban areas, but McCarthy pointed out that any faster housing response would likely require further deregulation of the process.

“Some of the proposals that we didn’t pass would have allowed a lot of ugly stuff, without a lot of regard to traffic or aesthetics,” he said. “I think there would be a huge backlash and outcry.”

Locally, St. Albans City will likely benefit the most from H.687, as it has extensive water and sewer infrastructure required for growth centers. H.687 could also allow faster development in a few areas of  St. Albans Town, but it’s unclear at this point what specifically would qualify under the new law.

Scenario 3: Some salaries catch-up; others fall behind

To better understand how the national housing crisis will end, J.P. Morgan conducted its own analysis of the state’s housing stock across 21 metropolitan cities, and the bank’s estimate is that the U.S. housing crisis would end in 3.5 years on average, or in the summer of 2027. Areas with the least affordable housing stock – like Miami – would take longer, roughly 10 years.

In J.P. Morgan’s potential scenario, the major variable that changed over time was an expected 7% growth in income levels combined with lowered interest rates. Basically, the nationwide bank estimated housing will become more affordable when people eventually make more money to afford the high prices.

There’s some evidence that Vermont is already seeing some of this scenario currently playing out as people with financial means are still building despite the logjam. New construction can still be spotted throughout the county although a new home costs over $450,000 on average.

Richford, Enosbugh, Montgomery, Franklin and Fairfield are also seeing their housing markets start to soften in comparison to the county’s fastest growing areas, such as St. Albans Town, Fairfax, Georgia and Fletcher.

“I would say a good chunk of my business, at least 40%, has been in Richford, Sheldon, Franklin – all those towns that are just a little bit further geographically that add 10 to 15 minutes to a commute,” Franklin County realtor Nicole Broderick said. “It’s a lot less competitive if you’re willing to make that extra trip.”

Broderick said she works with a lot of first-time homebuyers who have been outbid time and time again in more competitive markets further south, but they’re still looking to find a home where they can build up wealth and equity over time. 

The average homebuyer, however, has gotten older – closer to mid-30s – and more established. They’re waiting to start families after starting careers, and they’re usually open to finding a “good” place over finding exactly what they want. Even with those high interest rates that prevent older generations from exploring the market, younger families are finding that mortgage prices for these homes are comparable to the inflated rental market, Broderick said, and they’re making it work. 

“The people approaching the housing scene are verbalizing that it’s their goal to have a house within a year. People are in this for the long haul,” she said. “I don't think there’s a magic number. Wait two years, or wait five years and we’ll have a surplus of housing. I think it’s going to come down to being creative and resourceful.”

Champlain Housing Trust, under Monte’s leadership, is also doing what it can with the resources available to create more permanent affordable housing, but since CHT’s clients tend to be lower on the socioeconomic ladder, the nonprofit often leans on non-traditional market solutions – such as public financing, shared lots, connected homes and other multi-unit options – to make it happen.

Looking forward to the future, Monte said Vermont will likely need more of these options in order to adequately address the full range of housing problems facing the state. Some people just won't be able to afford a single-family home, and it’s important to have housing options for people at every income level.

“If everyone wants a single family home and that’s what we’re building, we’ll never be able to create enough housing,” he said. 

With their unique approach, CHT has sold 365 homes, and they have 200 starting up or in construction over the next year. While the number won’t fix Vermont’s larger housing problem, the work can greatly benefit the average homebuyer, as well as make impacts on the market in some way, Monte said. He’d also like to see the state set aside a designated funding source to help jumpstart the work. 

Lots done, more to do

While the larger housing market works out the kinks, the State of Vermont has been more than active in trying to solve the issue. Social workers have used state funds to set up housing for some of the most vulnerable populations, such as people dealing with homelessness, and nonprofit developers have helped create buildings for seniors living on fixed incomes. Funds are available for first-time homebuyers, as well as property owners who need help making repairs. Millions have been spent catalyzing construction, restoring blighted buildings and remediating brownfields. Planning officials have re-written town zoning codes across the state. Flooded houses have been purchased or repaired. Committees have met. Legislators have argued. 

Housing in Vermont, however, shows no signs of getting any more affordable any time soon, and no one knows exactly what is going to happen next. But something will happen, sometime. 

Until then, housing experts offer this advice: Do what you can.

“There are a lot of different organizations talking about what our next step is going to be,” Monte said. “I’m a firm believer you have to plant the tree today.”  

“The market is still out there. It’s still very competitive and still very fast-paced. There’s still a huge need for housing and interest rates are not stopping people from purchasing. They still want and need that equity, and property is going to be an asset,” Broderick said. “None of us hold the magic-8 ball.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here