What is H. 169? Upcoming bill seeks to change Department of Children and Families procedures in Vermont

Posted

MONTPELIER — As debates over child care continue throughout Vermont, one bill that has been making waves across the state is H. 169.

Introduced to the 2023 legislative session this past February, the bill seeks to make significant changes to the proceedings and processes of the Department of Children and Families. It’s still being worked on by the House Judiciary Committee. 

The bill looks to make amendments to substantiation, the process through which the department finds “substantiated concern” in child abuse and neglect investigations. 

According to a 2022 report by Vermont Parent Representation Center (VPRC), DCF opens over 3,000 child abuse and neglect investigations every year, 30% of which are substantiated. 

With this number of substantiations, VPRC executive director Larry Crist said it is pertinent that a bill like this is able to make its way through the legislature. Yet the goals the bill is trying to accomplish are not so easily met. 

Bill proposals 

Much of H. 169 focuses on changing the processes by which DCF conducts substantiations. One change the bill takes aim at is extending time limits for substantiation processes. Currently, those who are substantiated by DCF have 14 days to appeal. 

But according to DCF, substantiations are mandated to be sent to a substantiation recipient’s last known address, and do not require confirmation that the recipient has received it. 

H. 169 proposes an extension of the time limit to respond to a substantiation from 14 days to 60 days. 

The bill also proposes to change the standard by which DCF determines after investigation that a child has been abused or neglected. DCF currently uses the standard that a “reasonable person” would be led to believe there is child abuse or neglect, which Crist said he feels is a non-standard. VPRC’s 2022 report found that only four U.S. states still use the “reasonable person” standard. 

The bill proposes to change this “reasonable person” standard to a standard with a “preponderance of evidence” that child abuse or neglect has occurred. 

Thirdly, the bill aims to reform the Vermont Child Protection Registry, a database that keeps track of substantiated child abuse and neglect reports. Created in 1992, the registry’s system needs to be updated to be concurrent with the modern age, said Rep. Tiffany Bluemle (D-Burlington), a co-sponsor of the bill. 

The bill seeks to create a tiered registry system that “balances the need to protect children and the potential employment consequences of a registry record for persons who are substantiated for child abuse and neglect.” 

Crist said with DCF being mandated by law to disclose registry findings to certain employers, some jobs in the state do not allow those on the registry to hold employment, including medical, nursing and teaching professions.

“Here we are now, some 20 years later, we now have roughly 25,000 names on the registry, ranging from the most minor interaction between parents and children to incredibly egregious child abuse, but they’re all treated much in the same way,” Crist said.  

H. 169’s co-sponsors are Rep. Bluemle and Rep. Gabrielle Stebbins (D-Burlington). Both said that while the bill takes aim at reforming DCF proceedings, the bill is not inherently against the department. Instead, it looks holistically at how the processes of the department can be improved.

“This is not an anti-DCF bill, this is intended to sure up the system, and all of the people who are engaged in it,” Bluemle said. “There may be differences of opinion between the department and the legislature next year, but there is general agreement that something needs to shift.” 

As a not-for-profit organization that provides legal support for substantiation appeals taken against DCF, VPRC also supports H. 169. 

Of the 30-some substantiation appeals VPRC has taken on, they have won every case. With VPRC cases being selected on a first-come, first-served basis, Crist said this exemplifies the real need for change in Vermont DCF substantiation policies. 

“If we selected these cases, I would say we can identify the specific problems in each case, but we can’t extrapolate…we didn’t select these, we didn’t cherry-pick or pre-screen,” Crist said.  

DCF response 

Vermont Department of Children and Families deputy commissioner Aryka Radke said there are some areas of H. 169 the department agrees with. Some reforms introduced in H. 169, Radke said, were already proposed in concurrent bill H. 327, which DCF wrote and put forth. 

That bill, also read in committee this past February, was referred to the Committee on Human Services. The bill also proposes extending the time limit of a required response to a substantiation claim, though the bill proposes an extension to 30 days, unlike the 60 days proposed in H. 169.

H. 327 also proposes the acceptance of substantiations when the individual requesting the review does not respond or appear, and permits virtual reviews of substantiations in the case of an emergency. 

Radke said there are some things in H. 169 that DCF is potentially amenable to changing that are also mentioned in H. 327. These include extending time limits on the subject of a substantiation seeking an administrative review from the department, and the standard of proof in substantiation cases being changed from the “reasonable person” standard to the “preponderance of evidence” standard, which Radke agreed is now more common on a state-by-state basis.

Along with these changes, DCF is also working to use a new database for their child welfare activities. According to Radke, a 2017 assessment concluded the systems the department uses for substantiation cases are outdated. 

DCF has advocated for a number of years to upgrade to a Comprehensive Child Welfare Information System, also known as a CCWIS, Radke said. And according to her, their efforts have been fruitful. 

“The first draft of the CCWIS Request for Proposal (RFP) was completed in early September and sent out to internal staff and federal partners for review,” Radke told the Messenger. “Once feedback has been provided, the draft will be updated and finalized and move on to the next step before being sent out to vendors.”

Yet along with the changes both DCF and H. 169 co-sponsors agree on, Radke said there are also parts of the bill the department does not believe are necessary.

“There is, in the bill, some discussion about not requesting court intervention absent of finding of abuse or neglect; for us, that would really turn our process on its head, because social and family services workers are always assessing risk,” Radke said. “There may be times where you may have an immediate risk where we may need to go in before there’s a full finding of abuse and neglect, but we may need to seek court involvement for the safety of the child.” 

Bluemle said H. 169’s intent is not to prevent children from protection offered by DCF, but rather to take a closer look at the systems DCF has put in place to protect children. 

“I feel it’s important that we’re not advocating that the pendulum swing back from trying to protect children, that is a really important responsibility of the state…systems are affected by so many things, they’re affected by whoever is governor, or the secretary of human services, habits accrue and people start doing things one way and it just kind of sticks,” Bluemle said. 

While Radke said DCF does take issue with some parts of the bill, she also said the department is amenable to discussions.

In fact, the department is looking to begin facilitating these discussions as soon as next month. 

Starting in November, DCF will be assembling a task force to discuss issues with the substantiation process. Radke said she presumes some co-sponsors of H. 169 will be able to participate, as well as other parties.

“It will be facilitated by a neutral party, because we really do want to have a robust conversation to make sure everyone’s voices are heard,” Radke said. 

Upcoming plans for H. 169

Bluemle, Stebbins and Crist all made clear that upcoming iterations of the bill will likely not remain exactly the same as it is currently proposed. 

Crist said future iterations may place an even greater emphasis on making DCF’s substantiation process the bill’s main focus. Stebbins said changes will inevitably be made as the bill makes its way through conversations in committee. 

“I do trust the process, in terms of how, by the end of May, 98% of the time the bills brought to the floor have really gone through deep review, deep analysis and a lot of considerable thought and they’re better,” Stebbins said. 

Yet both Bluemle and Stebbins said their goal for the upcoming session is to have a productive conversation about what can be done to address purported issues with DCF proceedings.

“Not being an expert…our deep hope is that we will see progress this session to make at least discreet changes that can improve things…also to have the broader conversation of what’s working and what’s not,” Stebbins said.

h. 169, department of children and families, legislative session

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here