ST. ALBANS CITY – Every year, warmer weather tends to bring more crime.
But will that lead to a repeat of what downtown St. Albans saw last year?
Standing in front of downtown merchants Wednesday morning, Lt. Jason Wetherby with the St. Albans Police Department called it a “loaded question.” At the end of the day, no one can tell the future.
Instead, Wetherby talked to business owners about their concerns in light of last year’s events. Basically, an increase in criminality in 2024 prompted an outstanding number of calls for service for the St. Albans Police Department, leaving many city officials scrambling to tamp down on increases in thefts, suspicious people and drug crimes.
Meanwhile, the downtown business community felt the brunt of a diminished customer base. Business owners explained Wednesday how some people stopped heading downtown altogether after seeing problems emerge.
So what will summer 2025 look like? Which crowds will be back?
“It’s hard to say,” planning director Chip Sawyer said.
Some businesses have already pulled from participating in downtown events in anticipation of problems. The Northwest Farmers’ Market, for example, has only half of its vendors returning this year after 2024’s bumpy summer.
As Sawyer explained, the City of St. Albans has been proactive in making changes to try to stop problematic behaviors from coming downtown. In response to last summer, the electric outlets in Taylor Park are now being turned off during nighttime hours, while the small portalets on the park’s east side are being locked except during events, he said. City workers found used needles in the port-a-potties last year.
The city also added more lights to Taylor Park as a way to keep the park lit and free from people camping there overnight. Sawyer pointed to efforts to clear out encampments of unhoused people, with spots near Food City and – then later – behind Domino’s vacated as proof of the city’s seriousness.
The St. Albans Police Department also wrapped up a major expansion it started last summer. Partnering with the Town of St. Albans, the police department was able to add four to their staff while launching a new-and-improved street crimes unit dedicated to uprooting drug networks.
More police foot patrols are also on the agenda for this summer, Wetherby said.
SAPD rolled out night patrols last year, and he said officers ended up catching a burglary in progress at From Scratch. He expects patrols to continue as long as police have the staffing.
But will those changes be enough? While explaining what’s been accomplished, Wetherby also got a few questions from business owners about what steps they could take to prevent problems when someone shows up. Should they call the cops? Should they verbally confront the individual? That’s a little harder to answer, Wetherby said.
“What legal grounds makes someone suspicious?” he said.
While the city works to tamp down on bad-faith actors, Sawyer explained that chasing people out of downtown can create some shaky legal foundations around individual rights, especially when the city is responsible for policing its public spaces.
On the flip side, it just takes one bad interaction for a business to lose a customer. If someone doesn’t feel safe, it doesn’t matter if they’re actually safe or not.
Sawyer said the city has to navigate those competing concerns every time it reacts to a potential issue, and Wetherby said SAPD got 11,500 calls for service last year – the highest he’s seen in his career. Many were for suspicious people.
“You don’t want to automatically look through the bad guy lens,” Wetherby said. “There’s a difference between paranoid and prepared.”
Instead, downtown’s problems are likely more complicated, consisting of a few different groups with different needs all co-existing.
For example, Wetherby explained some people are more brazen in their criminality, with a “devil may care” attitude about their future prospects. When they get cited or arrested, they don’t have much reason to follow through with a court appearance.
“They’re some brazen people. Some we’ve dealt with 100s of times,” he said.
And then there are serial shoplifters. Wetherby explained some people drop into big box stores during day trips to make a haul without paying. Those folks are harder to catch.
Many calls for service, however, end up missing the mark. Wetherby explained it’s difficult to always know if someone means harm or not, and there are inherent problems with assuming what someone will do or how they’ll act depending on how they look.
But he did encourage business owners to stay vigilant just in case. If someone comes into a shop and starts acting shady, they can always ask that person questions to figure out what someone may be doing. And sometimes that extra pressure is all they’ll need to chase away a future issue.
Despite getting repeated calls around vehicle thefts throughout this past summer, Wetherby said there was a singular incident when someone actually broke into a vehicle. Every other time, they checked the door handles.
“It might be time to make the change to start locking your doors,” Wetherby said.
Downtown manager Arleigh Young also encouraged business owners to work together to head off problems. Getting to know neighbors could be helpful to rally some back-up depending on the situation.
“That way the community won’t feel quite so on its own, feeling like we’re out here by ourselves,” Young said.