FRANKLIN COUNTY — In their first electoral match-up in 2022, John Lavoie won 1,800 more votes than his competitor, Zach Weight, to win the job as Franklin County State’s Attorney.
A lot has happened since.
Lavoie resigned from the state’s attorney’s role a year later in 2023 after he made inappropriate comments to his colleagues that resulted in a state investigation.
Now, he’s running to get his former job back.
“At the end of the day, if there’s another murder on Main Street, do you want the guy with 30 years of experience prosecuting it, or the guy who just became a prosecutor,” John Lavoie said. “I hope that people understand what’s important.”
“I don’t think going back to a failed model … is going to get us anywhere, so I put myself forward, and I’m having great conversations with people. I think people are receptive to it. I know the system itself and the actors within the system are receptive to it,” Zach Weight, who began his legal career in 2014, said. “We’ll just see what the voters say in November.”
The Franklin County State’s Attorney functions as the county’s lead prosecutor responsible for choosing which criminal cases to pursue in Franklin County’s court system and plays a large role in determining case outcomes, including identifying potential charges and organizing plea agreements.
As Lavoie explains it, problems at the Franklin County State’s Attorney’s Office began not long after Jim Hughes retired from the office.
During Hughes’ tenure, Lavoie worked in the office as a deputy state’s attorney alongside a few other veteran prosecutors who had worked in the office for decades. But when Hughes left, the leadership position opened up without a named successor, and few people wanted to go through the process of running for office, he said.
So he figured he’d give it a shot in 2022, eventually taking over the office after winning the election against Weight in their first contested race.
Despite gaining voters’ confidence that year, Lavoie’s approach quickly hit a roadblock, likely for a few reasons. First, Lavoie’s management style differed from Hughes hands-off approach, and a few veteran prosecutors, too, bristled at some of the changes he proposed, he said.
There was also Lavoie’s use of language. By that spring, staff members had noted Lavoie’s crude and disrespectful comments directed at women, minorities and disabled people on repeated occasions, and they reached out to Vermont’s Department of State’s Attorneys and Sheriffs, which instigated an investigation into the office.
Months later, the Vermont House of Representatives then initiated its Special Committee on Impeachment, packaging the actions of Lavoie together with Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore in order to look into allegations of misconduct stemming from the two offices.
Under plenty of public pressure — heightened by the state’s evidence filed against him — Lavoie resigned soon after in the hope his actions would help the office get back on its feet, he said.
“My understanding was when I quit that things would stop, that would give the office a chance to get back to normal, and somebody else would take over, who would sort of heal the office,” he said.
But that’s not exactly how it went. In the aftermath, Gov. Phil Scott appointed Bram Kranichfeld — a prosecutor and pastor — who came to the office looking to mediate some of the standing issues.
“First of all, the office has suffered from some trauma over the last year,” Kranichfeld told the Messenger in 2023. “And I think that’s both institutional trauma to the office, and it’s personal trauma to the people in the office. There’s this need for healing.”
By both Weight’s and Lavoie’s counts, just two people remain at the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office in the aftermath of the 2023 shake-up. Kranichfeld is also on his way out after running for Chittenden County’s State’s Attorney. But he lost in the primary election this past August.
“I think (Kranichfeld) got thrown into a hornet’s nest, essentially,” Lavoie said. “And it took him a sec to figure out that I wasn’t the problem. And then he started running into the same sort of problems that I did.”
Zach Weight didn’t start his legal career thinking he’d become a prosecutor, but an early gig with the Addison County’s State’s Attorney Office changed that.
“I just loved it,” he said. “And I like being in a courtroom, dealing with criminal issues, criminal cases. … That really lit a passion in me,” he said.
Originally from the Proctor and Wallingford area in Rutland County, Weight said he initially imagined a legal job doing some sort of policy work for the statehouse, but he soon found that he much preferred to be in a courtroom.
As his first job as a lawyer in 2014, he took a position with Northeast Kingdom Law working in public defense in Orleans County, which led to a similar role at Burke Law in Burlington, where he stayed until 2023.
By then, he got a job with the Washington County State’s Attorney Office as a deputy state’s attorney, where he's been working since — outside of his time spent with Chittenden County’s Accountability Court as a special prosecutor.
Gov. Phil Scott appointed him to the court in 2025 as part of an effort to help clear out the backlog of “service-resistant repeat offender criminal cases.”
“I believe Zach has the skills needed to take on this role as we focus on holding repeat offenders accountable and connecting people to the services they need,” Gov. Phil Scott said in a press release at the time. “I’m hopeful this short-term assignment will help address some of the issues facing Burlington and know Zach will serve Vermont well.”
If elected, Weight said he’d bring his experience from the accountability court to Franklin County, especially when it comes to bringing community resources together.
“I really believe that starts at a competent and engaged state’s attorney,” he said.
To make it happen, the state’s attorney office would talk with organizations like NCSS, Turning Point and Franklin Grand Isle Restorative Justice to encourage more collaborative and coordinated initiatives to better deal with habitual offenders and help clear the court’s backlog.
Weight said he’s already started talking with law enforcement agencies and some community justice partners who are looking for such leadership from the state’s attorney’s office.
“The perception that I am left with is that all of these different elements of our Franklin County criminal justice system are basically waiting and hoping for leadership from the state’s attorney’s office, and some of them have told me point blank that since Jim Hughes left, they haven’t had that,” Weight said.
He also points a finger at Lavoie for being the one in charge when a lot of the instability came down the line — a point Lavoie readily admit.
“I don’t want any of my talk about the impeachment proceedings, or my subsequent resignation to sound like some excuse for my behavior, because if I hadn’t used inappropriate language in the workplace, there couldn’t have been an issue,” Lavoie said.
As Weight explains it, the biggest difficulties the Franklin County court system encounters revolve around not being able to quickly deal with the cases that habitually drag down proceedings.
He said there’s roughly 15 to 30 people he categorized as “habitual offenders” who are regularly involved with the court system, on sometimes a weekly or monthly basis, as they tend to wrack up additional charges while waiting for earlier cases to move through the system.
By taking a careful look across service silos, Weight said the court system could better identify those individuals, understand what’s been done so far to get them help and potentially resolve those issues that keep driving some of their bad behaviors.
“What we have found is that the criminal justice system is kind of the end of the road for a lot of people,” he said. “And for whatever reason, the State of Vermont has not invested in exits so people can take an off-ramp to go get help and support.”
An example is the lack of places to stay for people who are dealing with mental health issues, he said. If someone needs help, they can end up staying in a hospital bed — which can drive up healthcare costs. Meanwhile, the Vermont Department of Mental Health just closed more beds at the Vermont Psychiatric Hospital after citing a lack of need.
As state’s attorney, he said he would try to reverse those kinds of state decisions by taking advantage of relationships he’s developed over the years with people like state Sen. Bob Norris, state Rep. Tom Oliver and state Rep. Joe Luneau, in order to better communicate what’s needed locally for the Franklin County court system to run more efficiently.
Additionally, he would like the office to be more communicative with other municipal entities throughout the county, emphasizing regular contact with selectboards and efforts like ride-alongs with police agencies, to help increase institutional trust.
His first steps, he said, would be hiring prosecutors to fill open positions and establish a new foundation for the office before building up the communication network externally.
“If you keep consistently showing up, doing good work and those walls start to crack and trust starts to build and people then all of a sudden want to work with you,” he said.
Following the August primary, Weight secured the nominations from both the Democratic and Republican parties. Lavoie filed to run as an independent.
“I made two promises four years ago in that (2022) campaign,” Weight said. “ … No matter what happens, whether I win or lose in 2022, I'm going to move to Franklin County and I'm going to become a prosecutor. I've done both those things because I believe in this, and I believe in this community, which is why my family and I moved here.
“And so, I believe I'm going to win this election. I believe I'm the best candidate for the Franklin County State's Attorney's Office,“ he added.
While Lavoie’s solution set for the office has similarities to Weight’s approach, Lavoie stresses his experience sets him apart, as he’s been a prosecutor with the Franklin County State’s Attorney office for more than three decades, after originally starting out in Brattleboro in 1988.
Lavoie said he first entered law school after he spent the first part of his career working as a newspaper photographer, and he was able to witness how law impacts the process, especially after getting arrested while on assignment in the mid-70s by an aggressive police officer.
By the late ‘80s, he had graduated from Vermont Law School and became interested in being a prosecutor.
“I got sold very early on that our jobs were a lot more than just being lawyers doing a job.
And if you sort of proceed in that way, I think the job can be very rewarding,” Lavoie said. “You might piss some people off along the way doing that, but if you are doing the right thing, that’s your job.”
Throughout the years, Lavoie worked alongside Hughes as they came from the same generation, but Lavoie tried to stay out of the limelight, leaving Hughes to take on the political side of the job while he concentrated on the ins-and-outs of prosecuting.
If voters return him to office, Lavoie said he’d bring that courtroom experience back to better lead, as he expressed misgivings with Weight’s prosecutorial ability. Instead, Lavoie said “accountability” has been used as a political buzz-word, as the office had been following a sequential intervention model before Scott set up Chittenden County’s Accountability Court.
The problem instead, Lavoie said, is there has been a softening of consequences. In years past, being jailed was often used as the punishment to get people to mend their ways after multiple infractions, but the institution of minimum sentences of zero jail-time has relinquished that leverage point, he said.
The court’s prioritization of cases also needs some work, and Lavoie said the fix is to get everyone back on a common understanding while also taking the time to be fair to both the victims and criminals.
“That involves both sides sort of understanding from day one that (high priority) cases are going to be dealt with expeditiously. Everybody needs to get on board with that,” he said.
Like Weight, Lavoie also emphasized the court system is often someone’s last chance, and the court needs to be fair when trying to understand someone’s circumstances. In many cases, they're dealing with lower-income people in greater frequency because “the economy has been on its head for a long time,” he said.
“You have to ask yourself: How did they get here? What is it that put them in a position where criminal activity was the choice?” he said.
With that said, Lavoie said Kranichfeld had been successful in some ways in re-establishing the office, but there had been too much discord to really get things moving.
“I hated what happened in the office, and I really hated that people didn’t give Bram a chance really to get his legs under him, and there was a sort of constant level of criticism but a lot of discord and a lot of a lack of continuity. And new people didn’t have a chance to get trained,” Lavoie said.
As for his prior behavior, Lavoie said he’s gone through additional training courses — as part of continuing education — and he recognizes how his lax approach when speaking to staff in the past created an uncomfortable situation, especially as management is expected to lead by example.
“Some of the stuff that I said was obviously hurtful to people, and shouldn't have been said,” Lavoie said.
And he expects voters to recognize the circumstances of how he got there, especially as he’s been a member of the community for more than three decades.
“My kids went to school here. We vote here. We pay taxes here. But people know me. I would encourage anyone who has a question about me to talk to somebody who’s known me for that period of time. And I thin they’ll vouch for me and my heart and my intentions,” he said.
Lavoie said he did consider retiring following his initial resignation, but after spending plenty of time with his hobbies, he’s ready to come back. After a few decades with the work, it’s what he knows how to do well.
“Ultimately, it was a nice little vacation, but then I really missed it,” he said.