‘Voting is my chance:' Young voters share their fears and hopes for upcoming election

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Young people are concerned for the future of the country.

“The USA is cooked,” 18 year-old Trey Desautels said. “Wouldn't be surprised if another civil war happens in the next few years with the tensions.”

This November, Desautels and others of his generation will cast ballots in a U.S. presidential election for the first time, coming of voting age during a period of extreme polarization and increasing distrust in politicians.

“This is not a normal year,” said Jonathan “Doc” Bradley, a lecturer in political science specializing in American politics at the University of Vermont. “I would argue this year’s election for president is probably the most important in 140 years.”

In addition to the uncertainty a typical voter may feel about the upcoming election, Bradley said young people face a unique disconnect between themselves and politicians. Young people tend to vote less than their elders, and as a result, politicians cater to older voters and the issues they care about.

“Young people, at least the students I deal with, feel their issues are not important, and that they don’t really have candidates to pick from,” Bradley said.

To better understand how young people in Franklin County feel about the upcoming election, the Messenger put out a survey asking young people ages 17-22 to share their hopes and concerns.

When asked what three issues survey respondents care the most about, abortion and reproductive rights (47.1%), economy and jobs (47.1%), the climate (41.2%) and housing (41.2%) were shown to be young peoples’ top priorities.

Issues surrounding health care (29.4%), education (35.3%), corruption (29.4%) and income inequality (29.4%) are also priorities for these voters. Issues involving federal taxes and spending, terrorism and national security, and substance use got one selection or less.

Despite the disconnect between politicians’ political promises and the issues young people prioritize, voting can offer young people an opportunity to counter the current political climate.

“I think the only way to really check the government is to vote,” Mackenzie Smith, a senior at BFA-St. Albans, said.

This fall, Smith will work alongside senior Lila Dumont and guidance counselor Stephanie Hodgeman to talk with students who are eligible to vote about the process and help them get registered.

“Having the power to vote who gets put in office at a local level, state level, national level is just so helpful and allows us to voice what we want and have our representation in government,” Smith said.

Many survey respondents agreed with Smith about the importance of voting. 70.6% of survey respondents stated they would definitely be voting in the next presidential election and 11.8% said they “probably” would.

When asked why they were voting in the next presidential election, an anonymous 18 year-old said “every vote matters.”

21 year-old Alex Trembley said: “I need to have an impact on the current situation in the world. Voting is my chance to do that.”

Local elections

This sentiment does not fully translate to local elections. While only 5.9% of respondents said that they “Probably” or “Definitely” would not vote in the presidential election, 31.3% said the same for local elections.

Robyn Palmer, director of civic and voter engagement at the Vermont Secretary of State’s Office, said participating in local government and politics can be challenging even for those who want to participate. Civic infrastructure is present in Vermont through a variety of small grassroots organizations and traditions like Town Meeting Day, but to those who have never participated or don’t know where to look, engaging for the first time can feel daunting.

“The biggest challenge in Vermont is how to make that infrastructure that does exist feel more welcoming to new people; it’s inviting everyone to participate in a way that feels accessible,” Palmer said.

While accessibility may be preventing some young people from participating, some survey respondents stated they were “not interested,” that they “don’t pay attention to local politics” or that it feels “slightly less important” than federal elections.

Bradley said local elections and politics are widely overlooked despite their power to create change. Local politics are more immediate and responsive to local citizens, while politics at the federal level can take anywhere from weeks to years to impact the average person’s life. These local elections are usually more important to the average person than a presidential one, but Bradley stressed this upcoming election is an outlier.

What’s at stake

Survey respondents planning to vote in both local and federal elections expressed notions of civic duty or the importance of having their voices heard. In contrast, many of those prioritizing presidential election appear to do so out of fear for the country’s future and their rights.

“Not voting is only adding to complicity in creating the dictatorship politicians want America to be, especially in such a vulnerable time where everyone wants to take our rights,” 18 year-old Luke Holcomb said.

An anonymous survey respondent said that as a queer person, a student and someone assigned female at birth, there are a number of national conversations that are deeply concerning.

“I consider voting to be the most I can do to secure a safer future for myself and many others,” they said.

These concerns coincide with widespread critiques about U.S. politics from young people.

76.5% of respondents agreed with the statement that “Political leaders do not face consequences if they act unethically” and 76.5% agreed with the statement that “Special interest groups and lobbyists have too much say in what happens in politics.”

Extreme polarization in particular was noted by respondents with 70.6% agreeing that “Republicans and Democrats are more focused on fighting each other than solving problems” and 41.2% saying the ability of Democrats and Republicans to work together was one of the top three problems currently facing the U.S – with inflation (41.2%), affordability of healthcare (35.3%) and climate change (41.2) as other major issues.

In a healthy civic state, people should feel safe to express opinions contrary to those of others. However, as citizens become more polarized, discussions involving disagreements become more challenging.

“The whole topic of respectful discussion and how to talk across differences is something that has just been a theme in almost every conversation I’ve had this year,” Palmer said. “People forget that it’s a skill that can be practiced. It’s not something you have or don’t have. We want to find new ways for people to exercise and practice that skill.”

Bradley said the polarization of the political parties began in 1992. During this time, the most conservative Democrat was more conservative than the most progressive Republican. This resulted in a center that contained members of both political parties. However, as polarization slowly increased, this center disappeared with the election of the 2011 Congress.

“For the first time, you saw in both the House and the Senate that the most conservative Democrat was still more progressive than the most progressive Republican. For the first time ever since the Civil War, we had the two parties clearly opposite to each other,” Bradley said.

The ability of politicians to work together is what makes government function, but the ability for compromise is often broken on major issues. The priority for politicians and parties has shifted from passing legislation through negotiation and compromise to trying to make the other side “lose.”

Bradley said this tribalist mentality explains how former President Donald Trump and President Joseph Biden have maintained the support of their parties, though the support of the latter by members of the Democratic Party has waned.

“With tribalism, you protect members of the tribe at all costs, and anything that is not part of the tribe is bad,” Bradley said. “Look at former President Trump. There’s no way in a normal party system that President Trump would be nominated. He’s got too much baggage, he’s got too many problems, but he’s a member, if not leader, of the tribe. No matter what happens or what he does, he has to be supported.

“You look at Joe Biden. Arguably, Joe Biden should not run because of his age and some of his mental capability. But still, the majority of the party is locked in step behind him because he’s a member of the tribe.”

Candidate choices

Prior to Biden dropping out of the presidential race, respondents to the Messenger’s survey were mostly dissatisfied with the two presumed front-runners of the election.

“Neither Biden nor Trump represent my views in the slightest,” an anonymous 19 year-old said.

Prior to Biden’s withdrawal from the race, the majority of respondents stated they would vote for Biden to be the next U.S. President. However, many expressed critiques with the candidate.

“Unfortunately, because of the two-party electoral college system we are subjected to, I’m forced to vote for Biden,” Holcomb said.

22 year-old Madison Randall said Biden’s “values align closer to mine, but I would prefer a different candidate.”

Trump was not spared from critiques. One 19 year-old said they are concerned about the Project 2025 “Mandate for Leadership” and fear it being implemented if the former president returns to office. Another 18 year-old described Trump as someone whose “intentions would spell disaster for America on countless levels.”

Other young people are considering third party candidates.

“The candidates for the two main parties are both incompetent in their own ways. Voting for a third party is the best option,” Desautels said.

Of those choosing to answer this question, 46% selected Biden, 23% selected Trump, 15.4% selected Robert F. Kennedy Jr, and 7.7% selected Cornel West.

One 19 year-old respondent said they feel Biden dropping out has “increased the excitement and engagement of all citizens” leading up to the election. With almost half of respondents saying they would vote for Biden, it is unclear if young voters will turn their support to Vice President Kamala Harris, who Biden endorsed as the Democratic nominee, or if other candidates will better align with youth priorities.

While this poll can not encompass the complex views of young voters, it provides valuable insight into young people’s thoughts, priorities and concerns leading up to the presidential election.

Though they remain concerned for their country, their continued belief in the importance of voting demonstrates their investment in its future.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here