Vermont considers dispatch fix; St. Albans City invests in regional approach

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — Call 911, and you can expect someone to be on the other line.

But who’s covering the cost?

Vermonters all equally rely on the state’s 911 dispatching system to beam information out to the first responding agencies that send help when emergencies happen, but some taxpayers are getting a better deal depending on where they live due to a lack of regulated funding.

Vermont is now looking to change that after the City of St. Albans has spent the last 20 years supporting Franklin County’s services. 

“We’ve made a lot of investment in the dispatch center itself, with the new police station and personnel that are a part of it,” City Manager Dominic Cloud said. “With that said, the state has been talking about this for 30 years. It’s optimistic we’re getting to a point where we’ll pull the trigger.”

Acting through its Public Safety Communications Task Force, Vermont still has plenty to do before the state’s designated committee knows how to effectively bolster Vermont’s dispatching system. 

Current efforts are focused around inventorying the 38 dispatch centers that comprise Vermont’s statewide system, but next steps include formulating the plan to see what’s possible to create a more regional approach.

Depending on what the state decides, St. Albans City could have a lot to gain, or to lose.

The St. Albans model

This past Town Meeting Day, the creation of a joint town/city St. Albans Police Department resulted in a larger tax increase for town residents. The reason? Dispatching costs. 

As part of the new agreement, town residents would be helping cover the administrative and capital costs city residents have covered since at least 2008, when St. Albans Central Dispatch began to function as the de-facto regional dispatch center for much of Franklin County. 

Over the years, costs have continued to expand though. While the same number of dispatchers work for St. Albans Central Dispatch, more and more people are calling for help. In 2008, 15,000 calls per year was normal. Today, there’s an additional 10,000 calls per year that dispatchers have to deal with. 

Most municipal actors have made up that difference with expensive technological improvements, rolling out major automated improvements to cut down on overall time per call. 

The problem with regionalizing in other parts of the state is that most places are not as dense as St. Albans City. Vermont’s rural landscapes and mountainous terrain often stack additional cost factors to doing business in the state, and dispatch services, by nature, require a broad network of antennas and amplifiers to connect the right people in a moment of crisis. Getting them all to work in coordination is a major task.

Improvements in digital technology have also pushed departments to continue to look at various ways to improve their own services and keep up with industry standards. In South Burlington, for example, the city utilized American Rescue Plan Act dollars and surplus funds to expand its own dispatch center this past spring, doubling it in size from two to four workstations. 

South Burlington Fire Chief Steven Locke said the new technology can help emergency workers save time as digital tools help take over some of tasks, like making calls over the radio.

“None of this is cheap,” Locke said. “So some part of it is making the investment in the infrastructure to run a good communication system.”

City of St. Albans budgeted $1.2 million to provide dispatch services in 2023, and last year’s investments also included a roughly $500,000 loan to install another dispatch tower — this time on Georgia Mountain — to expand services south and further west.

The tactic could help the city pick up additional emergency service groups as customers, like those in Grand Isle County. Fire departments as far north as Alburgh currently utilize Shelburne’s dispatch services.

“There’s some natural synergy,” Cloud said. “Whenever everybody is providing mutual aid to each other on the same communication system, it’s a lot more efficient.” 

“More and more of them are seeing the writing on the wall and joining the regional program,“ he added. “Dispatch is uniquely-suited for regionalization because you‘ve got small communities that need to have 24-hour access but don’t have a lot of call volume.”

Getting feedback

While Vermont officials examine regionalization efforts to curb costs and ultimately decrease response times, the state is also looking to hear from the public.

Starting Sept. 11, the Public Safety Communications Task Force will be holding four separate listening sessions to understand what public stakeholders want from their dispatch systems. 

The first is scheduled to be held at Swanton Town Hall, 1 Academy St., from 5 to 7 p.m. on Sept. 11, to cover the northwest portion of the state. Additional meetings will be held later that week in Pittsford, St. Johnsbury and Springfield.

During the meetings, public stakeholders will get a chance to hear what the task force has already been able to accomplish, as well as give general public feedback about what they would like the state to pursue and/or avoid around regional dispatching.

The latest updates provided by the state lay out the committee hired two specialized firms to help create an in-depth inventory of what Vermont’s 38 existing dispatch centers have to work with. A more expanded plan on what to do with those assets is expected to be released closer to December. 

After that, it’s anybody’s guess. The difficulty of providing dispatching services has always been a tough one, and regionalization isn’t exactly a hot topic in Vermont. 

Back in 2016, for example, the Chittenden County Public Safety Authority began moving toward its own regional dispatching model by using a more complicated unified district system — essentially creating a separate utility-based, quasi-government — to stand up dispatch services for eight major municipalities.

By 2023, the momentum had fizzled. Just four of the original eight were still on board after Colchester left that year. The Milton Police Department decided to create a dispatching contract with St. Albans City instead of maintaining its investment in the CCPSA.  

Despite the moves, Locke said the need is still there. An earlier joint committee study estimated the regionalization effort could save 71 seconds per call by eliminating transfer calls, and the CCPSA could still be re-organized to continue the work. 

“It’s desperately needed for the fire and EMS world, and as the demand for services go up, the best way to do that is to share resources,” Locke said. 

But then — if nothing is done — cities and towns have already learned to make do with the status quo.

“I would be interested in a statewide funding formula,” Cloud said. “It’s not about local control. It’s about effective governance for me. I’d be glad to give up control if someone could do it better and cheaper.” 

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here