GRANBY, QUEBEC — The relationship between Vermont and Quebec is starting to feel the strain from President Donald Trump’s 35% tax on Canadian trade.
This past Friday, mayors from the two regions met in Granby to talk about what they plan to do about it.
“We came here to Granby, Quebec, because we want to highlight the long-standing bonds between governments, our communities and people of Vermont and Quebec,” Emma Mulvaeny-Stanak, the mayor of Burlington, said on the steps of Granby’s hotel de ville, surrounded by both Canadian and American mayors. “And to reaffirm our commitment to maintaining our economic, social and cultural partnerships.”
After months of negotiations between the U.S. and Canada, Trump’s White House released the following statement July 31, explaining why Canada was getting higher tariffs imposed “for its continued role in the illicit drug crisis.”
“Given Canada’s continued failure to arrest traffickers, seize illicit drugs, or coordinate with U.S. law enforcement and Canada’s retaliation against the United States for the President’s actions to address the unusual and extraordinary threat to America, further presidential action is necessary and appropriate to protect American lives and the national security and foreign policy of the United States.”
The economic impacts on Vermont, however, are hard to gauge.
St. Albans Mayor Tim Smith said Friday’s conversations in Granby between the two mayor groups primarily focused on how the two economies and two populations are starting to pull apart after cross-border business was disincentivized via the federal tariffs, as downturns have been noted on both sides.
Mulvaney-Stanak, for example, explained how business at Burlington's North Beach Campground has seen a 30% decrease in reservations, while fewer and fewer Canadian pilots are turning out at the Burlington airport.
Smith said there’s also been a stagnation in the amount of interest from Canadian companies looking at Franklin County. As the executive director of the Franklin County Industrial Development Corp., he will often help businesses find properties in order to better access American markets and shipping networks, but there’s been a decrease in companies interested.
Part of the difficulty has been the “instability” around the situation, Quebec’s mayors pointed out at the conference.
Guillaume Tremblay, mayor of Mascouche and president of the Union of Municipalities of Quebec, said it was a topic they spoke a lot about during Friday’s meeting between the groups, noting that the repercussions in both countries are quite similar – worried people anxious about losing their jobs and businesses disinvesting.
“Pourquoi? Parce qu’il y a beaucoup d'instabilité,” he said.
Since announcing the tariffs in April, the Trump administration has made multiple alterations and tax increases on cross-border trade, due to alleged problems around fentanyl trafficking. Just this past July as negotiations between Trump and Canada’s prime minister, Mark Carney, seemed to be reaching a better spot, the White House increased tariffs by 10%, citing fentanyl concerns.
Canadian officials, however, estimate less than one percent of all fentanyl reaching the U.S. comes across the northern border.
In response, Canadians have already taken actions to cut its ties to the U.S. economy. At the beginning of August, Montreal’s government announced the use of $1.3 million in the city’s upcoming budget to help push back against the confusion stemming from the trade war, with the funds being used to help Montreal businesses identify suppliers and customers outside of the U.S.
“We heard stories of Canadian businesses that are desperate because of the additional costs,” Smith said. “The exports of their projects have dropped right off.”
While cross-border business deals with tax challenges, Smith said the mayors from both Quebec and Vermont also noted a decrease in the number of people moving across the border.
It seems fewer Canadians see the United States as a destination, and Americans have worries that they aren't welcome in Canada due to Trump’s aggressive rhetoric, Smith said. Based on Smith’s experience, however, that hasn’t been the case.
“We’ve been up a few times, and haven’t encountered that,” he said. “There’s some hesitation that the reception in Canada may not be welcoming and I would dare say that’s far from the truth.”
Friday’s conference in Granby signaled just as much, as the two groups stood together in solidarity.
“We want to make sure that Canadians feel welcome. They feel encouraged to come to our cities and towns and our rural landscapes in Vermont, because that is critical for the well being of our economy and vice versa, encouraging Vermonters just to travel north, to also engage with all of the municipalities north of the board,” Mulvaney-Stanak said. “We don’t have to change our patterns because of what the president’s choosing to do.”
Going forward, Smith said both Vermont and Quebec mayors agreed they’d continue to meet more frequently to discuss their various challenges, potentially bringing in federal representatives during such discussions to help. Even with 35% tariffs slowing down business, they can still act independently to reach better outcomes.
“Both sides understand the value of building those relationships, and not let them go by the wayside because of what’s coming out of D.C.,” Smith said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here