SWANTON — The State of Vermont faces a few headwinds trying to reverse its economic challenges, and this past week, state legislators and Swanton residents got together to discuss some potential solutions.
From education to housing, the conversation ranged widely, but it did provide some insights into the various avenues being considered as elected officials and politicians work to untie a complicated knot of problems — such as housing, healthcare and education issues — impacting residents.
Last Thursday’s panel included Rep. Matt Walker (R-Swanton), Rep. Tom Oliver (R-Sheldon) and Sen. Bob Norris (R-Sheldon). Sen. Randy Brock (R-Swanton) joined the group by the tail end of the meeting due to a prior engagement.
Members of the Swanton Enhancement Project, who organized the event, also invited three candidates for office into the discussion. They included Tamar Bouchard, running as a Democrat for the Franklin-4 District, as well as Alexander Bobella and Greg Rainville, who are both running under the Democratic ticket for Franklin County’s Senate seats.
As Kiersten Bourgeois explained, Swanton Enhancement Project members invited the group to have a conversation instead of a political debate about potential solutions, as they were interested in how state legislators could “support Swanton’s continued growth and vitality.”
“This isn’t a debate. This is not an endorsement. This is a conversation,” she said.
The result largely focused on two closely-related subjects — education and workforce. Politicians from both parties agreed the steady hollowing of Vermont’s workforce is something that needs to be reduced as many of the state’s issues arise from the same problem — its deepening demographic imbalance.
Back in 1997, for example, the state’s demographic cross-section could better support the state’s initiatives due to the majority of Vermonters being working-age adults. Since that time, the number of Vermonters over age 65 has almost doubled, leaving today’s current-age adults with diluted influence on the state’s economy, exacerbated by 25 years of stagnant population growth in Vermont.
For three years — 2021, 2022 and 2023 — Vermont did see a spike of domestic immigration likely due to nationwide disruptions around the COVID-19 pandemic, but state officials couldn’t capitalize on the shift. Now, federal actors are disinvesting from state programs and causing economic uncertainties with Quebec, further complicating the situation.
“Affordability as a concept has kind of flown out the window, and a lot of us are being left behind,” Bobella commented. As a social worker employed with University of Vermont, he said he’s seeing many of the challenges from the people he works with on a regular basis.
“We have people leaving the state, we need to slow that down,” Norris said. “We need to create situations for them to want to be here. Last year, I think we lost 1,800 people who moved out of the state of Vermont. It's not a good thing.”
Molly Lambert, an SEP member, asked the group how economic development and education could be examined together to better address both issues, as they’re often two sides of the same coin. Students graduating from Vermont schools, in theory, should be able to enter Vermont’s workforce.
“We're paying an enormous amount to educate our students,” Lambert said. “The results of testing have not been as high as others in the country, but connecting the dots (of education and economic development) is what we really depend on the government to do.”
Everyone at the table agreed it’s a close link and that education can help with future growth by helping students gain skills needed in the area, especially around the trades.
“You try to find a plumber, try to find an electrician, try to find any of the trades. Most of the people have gray hair like me. There are very few younger people coming up in any of the trades,” Rainville said.
Bouchard, running for Swanton’s Franklin-4 district, said four of her five children ended up moving out of the area after finding a lack of opportunity post-graduation.
“Whether it’s California, or Nova Scotia, Canada or Brunswick, Maine, or anywhere else, they have been able to find much better situations than they could find here at home,” she said.
As the discussion approached the topic of the quality of Vermont’s education, Julie Regimbal, superintendent of Missisquoi Valley School District, pushed back against general qualifiers while sitting in the audience, saying the Missisquoi Valley schools have been doing their part to ensure students can find jobs.
“Ensuring our kids have high employability has been a big community ask of our school system and we've been doing that.” she said. “We have work-based learning. We have kids having internships at Husky, and all of the advanced manufacturing around here.”
At the same time, MVU is preparing students for college at higher rates than Swanton’s existing educational attainment rates, with just under half of students, or 44%, collegebound, she said.
While that may be the case, Norris pointed out there’s 40,000 fewer students in Vermont’s schools than when Act 60 was passed in the late ‘90s, and as a member of the Senate Appropriations Committee, he said there are many people putting pressure on the legislature to make education more affordable.
“The other side of the coin is people are saying we can't continue doing this. This track, we can't afford it. I'm talking about affordability,” he said. “Everybody here wants to give our students the best, okay, no one's going to disagree with that. But at what cost?”
While the latter half of the conversation focused on education and workforce, state legislators did take the time to explain some of the latest initiatives they’ve helped with in the statehouse.
Rep. Walker, for example, who is head of the House Committee on Transportation, said legislators were able to increase spending for road and bridge infrastructure to fund needed road repairs, and they added a fee to electric vehicle drivers (as of Jan 1.) to ensure the state can collect equitable taxes, as they already charge a tax on gas.
After former legislator Don Collins asked about a welcome center between Swanton and the border, Walker also confirmed that the project — after two decades of trying to get the state to move — has made it “into the transportation book.”
As for the other legislators on hand, Norris highlighted the tax breaks for veterans and farmers passed by the legislators, which he supported, as potential economic catalyzers.
Additionally, Rep. Oliver — who sits on the state’s judicial committee — spoke about his ongoing work there, highlighting bail reform, his support for police unions, as well as his work increasing the funding for the urban search and rescue team.
Speaking at the end of the meeting, Sen. Brock also named some of the issues he’s seen during his time in the statehouse. He emphasized the state government needs to consider how to do things quicker, and to find ways to make sure people are held accountable when things go wrong, or when projects languish for years without progress.
“I've been in business for many many years. I've been in government for many many years before that, including the military. And one of the things I've learned is that when things aren't going well and people aren't performing, you have to act to make changes, and we don't do that, and we don't do it fast enough, and we don't do it well enough,” he said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here